The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutAgenda Packet - BC - 2023.06.01• City of Burlingame BURLINGAME CITY HALL 501 PRIMROSE ROAD BURLINGAME BURLINGAME, CA 94010 F I� Meeting Agenda Beautification Commission Thursday, June 1, 2023 6:30 PM Burlingame Community Center 850 Burlingame Avenue Members of the public may view the meeting by logging into the Zoom meeting listed below. The meeting video will be uploaded to the City's website after the meeting. Members of the public may provide written comments by email to vflores@burlingame.org. Emailed comments should include the specific agenda item on which you are commenting or note that your comment concerns an item that is not on the agenda or is on the Consent Calendar. The length of the emailed comment should be commensurate with the three minutes customarily allowed for verbal comments, which is approximately 250-300 words. To ensure that your comment is received and read to the Beautification Commission for the appropriate agenda item, please submit your email no later than 5:00 PM on August 4, 2022. The City will make every effort to read emails received after that time but cannot guarantee such emails will be read into the record. Any emails received after the 5:00 PM deadline which are not read into the record will be provided to the Beautification Commission after the meeting. Please click the link below to join the webinar. https://us02web.zoom. us/j/87987147666?pwd=SXd6ai9EYV13NmdKaVQvTkwwMERrQT09 Passcode: 617960 Or One tap mobile: +16694449171„87987147666#,,,,*617960# US +16699006833„87987147666#,,,,*617960# US (San Jose) Or Telephone: Dial(for higher quality, dial a number based on your current location): +1 669 444 9171 US +1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose) +1 346 248 7799 US (Houston) +1 719 359 4580 US +1 253 205 0468 US +1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma) +1 301 715 8592 US (Washington DC) +1 305 224 1968 US +1 309 205 3325 US +1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago) +1 360 209 5623 US +1 386 347 5053 US +1 507 473 4847 US +1 564 217 2000 US +1 646 9313860 US +1 689 278 1000 US +1 929 205 6099 US (New York) Webinar ID: 879 8714 7666 Passcode: 617960 City of Burlingame Page 1 Printed on 5/26/2023 Beautification Commission Meeting Agenda June 1, 2023 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. ROLL CALL 3. MINUTES A. April 6. 2023 BBC Draft Minutes Attachments: Draft Minuets 4. CORRESPONDENCE 5. FROM THE FLOOR Speakers may address the Commission concerning any matter over which the Commission has jurisdiction or of which it may take cognizance that is not on the agenda. Additional public comments on agenda action items will be heard when the Commission takes up those items. The Ralph M. Brown Act (the State local agency open meeting law) prohibits the Commission from acting on any matter that is not on the agenda. Speakers are asked to fill out a "request to speak" card located on the table by the door and hand it to staff, although provision of name, address or other identifying information is optional. Speakers are limited to three minutes each, although the Commission may adjust the time limit in light of the number of anticipated speakers. 6. OLD BUSINESS A. Trees of Burlingame Ad Hoc Committee Members Update B. Residential and Business Landscape Award Update 7. NEW BUSINESS A. Protected Tree Removal Appeal - 1515 Floribunda Avenue Attachments: Staff Report Exhibit A - Email to Property Owner Re: the Protected Tree Permitting Process Exhibit B - City Arborist Removal Approval Letter Exhibit C - Two Appeals Protesting the Removal of Two Protected Trees Exhibit D - Arborist Report from Mathey Tree Care Exhibit E - Photos of Hemlock Tree Exhibit F - Photos of Juniper Tree City of Burlingame Page 2 Printed on 512612023 Beautification Commission Meeting Agenda June 1, 2023 Consideration of Changing the Themed Block Tree Species for the 1600-1700 Block of Easton Drive Attachments: Staff Report Exhibit A - Easton Drive Heritage Grove Designation 1976 Exhibit B - Long -Range Reforestation Plan for Easton Drive Exhibit C - Lemon Gum Recommendation (Australia) Exhibit D - Lemon Gum Do Not Plant List (Australia) Exhibit E - Lemon Gum Branch Failure Rate Discussion (Australia) Exhibit F - Petition Letter 1600 Bock of Easton Drive Exhibit G - Petition Letter 1700 Block of Easton Drive Exhibit H - 1500-2000 Block Easton Signatures Exhibit I - 1500-2000 Blocks Easton Drive Map Exhibit J - Trees to Be Planted in Areas 6' Wide and Over 8. REPORTS 9. UPCOMING AGENDA ITEMS Next Regular Meeting: July 6, 2023 Notice: Any attendees wishing accommodations for disabilities should contact the Parks & Recreation Dept. at (650) 558-7330 at least 24 hours before the meeting. A copy of the agenda packet is available for review at the Recreation Center, 850 Burlingame Avenue, during normal office hours. The Agendas and minutes are also available on the City's website: www.burlingame.org. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Burlingame Beautification Commission regarding any items on this agenda will be made available for public inspection at 850 Burlingame Avenue during normal business hours. City of Burlingame Page 3 Printed on 5/26/2023 BURLINGAME BEAUTIFICATION COMMISSION Draft Minutes April 6, 2023 The regularly scheduled meeting of the Beautification Commission was called to order at 6:31 pm by Commissioner Batte. 120] A WWI 0 Present: Commissioners Batte, Kirchner, Chu, and Khoury Absent: Chair Bauer Staff: Parks and Recreation Director Glomstad, Parks Superintendent/City Arborist Holtz, and Recording Secretary Flores Others: None MINUTES Commissioner Kirchner made a motion to approve the March 2, 2023, Regular Meeting minutes as written. The motion was seconded by Commission Chu and was approved 4-0-1. CORRESPONDENCE Secretary Flores informed the Commission of an email correspondence that was received for the theme block petition of the 1600 block of Easton Drive. She explained that staff would present it at the next regular meeting when the item was on the agenda. Also, she read an email correspondence from Burlingame resident Doug Boj ack that thanked staff for their dedication and hard work addressing the challenges and maintenance of City trees during the storms. Further, he explained the significance of the Annual Growth Award from the Arbor Day Foundation. He encouraged the City to pursue this designation in addition to the Tree City USA designation. PUBLIC COMMENT Eylul Stobaugh, a Burlingame resident, presented her concerns over the Eucalyptus trees throughout the City. She explained that there is a fear of past and future fatalities, the danger they pose to Burlingame High School students, and the fire hazard they represent. She requested that the City create a path to prioritize the safe removal of old Eucalyptus trees in front of homes, offices, and schools. Easton Drive Residents Julie Cockle and Amandeep Khurana echoed similar thoughts to Ms. Stobaugh. They explained that Easton Drive is a Theme Block, and any removed Eucalyptus tree is expected to be replaced with a new species of Eucalyptus. Ms. Cockle expressed her concerns for life safety due to the size of these trees. She noted that she was evacuated earlier this year due to potential tree failure. She submitted a petition to change the theme block of 1600 Eaton Drive to a native tree that is shorter and does not present the same risks. She offered statistics on the high risk of limb failure of Eucalyptus trees. Sanchez Avenue resident, Ray Brayer, spoke of his experience interning for the Burlingame Public Works Department and the damage caused to streets, sidewalks, curbs, and gutters by Eucalyptus trees due to their invasive root system. Further, had said they cause visibility issues that affect traffic. He asked that the City find an alternative species with a better root system, smaller trunk, less shed of debris, and not as water intensive. Jennifer Pfaff, a Burlingame resident, spoke about the Theme Block of Easton Drive, which is based on the number of trees in the area and the history of the tall canopy. She explained that the chosen replacement is meant to be as close as possible to what was there previously but more manageable and safer. She presented excerpts from two articles about the benefits of Eucalyptus trees. Lastly, she expressed her gratitude for the Burlingame Parks Division, which is dedicated to the safety, beauty, and respect for our cultural resources, including the one on Easton Drive. Drake Avenue resident Christine Ackerman thanked the Commission and staff for the speaking platform, transparency, and responsiveness. She explained that although decisions that were made previously made sense then, the current atmospheric rivers and severe wind events create a real hazard. She emphasized that the portion of the City's urban forest being commented on is a small percentage of the more than managed by the City. Ms. Ackerman stated that the City is not acting severely or swiftly enough to remove these trees posing a threat. She would like to see a clear path of removal of these trees, particularly when they have been deemed a risk to public health, as well as a midterm solution of reconsidering the Theme Block on Easton Drive. Burlingame resident Leslie McQuaide explained that she was chair of the Beautification Commission when the Easton Drive Theme Block designation was established. She provided a brief history of how the Eucalyptus theme came to be and why it was decided to have the citriodora as the best replacement species for the Blue Gum. She agrees that the Blue Gum is a big, heavy, and high -maintenance tree, but large trees serve as an important part of our history to maintain beautiful growth. Charlotte Petri, a resident of Burlingame Avenue, shared her concerns about the Australian native Eucalyptus trees. She stated that residents who do not have Eucalyptus on or around their property do not understand the challenges homeowners face with these trees. OLD BUSINESS 1. Trees of Burlingame Ad Hoc Committee Members Update Commissioner Kirchner explained that the Trees of Burlingame booklet was published in 1977 and that the Beautification Commission was charged to re -publish it. The latest chapter has just been put out for review and is predicting the future of Burlingame's urban trees. He stated that the chapter talks about different components that affect trees, such as age, environment, sea rise, city policy, etc. Commissioner Khoury is tasked with the last chapter regarding Washington Park. 2. Residential and Business Landscape Award Update Commissioner Chu provided an update on the Residential and Business Landscape Award and summarized what was discussed at the last BBC meeting. He explains that further discussion will occur at the June meeting once nominations are made for residential and business landscapes. Commissioner Khoury stated that she has personally been reaching out and distributing nomination forms to business owners to encourage nominations. NEW BUSINESS 1. Maintenance Program for City Trees City Arborist Richard Holtz provided a brief history of trees in Burlingame since the first tree protection ordinance started in 1908. He stated that the City has over 17,000 trees that the City of Burlingame owns, but that our Urban Forest refers to every tree within city limits that collectively contribute to the benefits we enjoy as a community. He explained the evaluation of our maintenance program, described the four- year grid pruning system currently established in the City, and reviewed the Emergency Response process. He stated that staff follow the Tree Risk Assessment Qualification (TRAQ) and described this assessment technique and the actions that follow. Further, he provided a synopsis of the winter storms and tree emergencies the City responded to earlier this year. Finally, he discussed the established street tree lists and Theme Blocks. He said that Burlingame is equipped for success in managing the large trees and provided a breakdown of the path forward to manage the Urban Forest. Commissioner Kirchner asked whether the citriodora replacement for the Eucalyptus tree removals is a policy or a desire. Arborist Holtz explained that the replacement species was discussed and established per the public Beautification Commission meeting in 2007 for the 1500-2000 block of Easton Drive. The only other area he knows is required is the Theme Blocks along Burlingame Ave. from the Community Center up to East Lane. Commissioner Kirchner referenced the Easton Library Eucalyptus tree as an example of a more mature citriodora near the Easton Library. Further, he stated that the Commission is advisory to the City Council. Director Glomstad clarified that the trees along El Camino Real are owned and maintained by Caltrans. Commissioner Chu asked if an analysis of the species composition of the trees that failed during the storms has been conducted and if a determination on whether certain species are more likely to fail. Arborist Holtz explained that 2,800 City -owned trees are Eucalyptus and that it is our most common tree. He has not done a full analysis of which trees failed but can confirm that the species that failed the most during the March 2023 storm were Eucalyptus. He stated that two of the four trees lost in Washington Park during the February storm were Redwood trees. He explained that the City had had multiple Eucalyptus failures due to different situations, such as soil and/or root failure. Public Comment Charlotte Petri stated that the impact of trees and people should be a priority when deciding what to do with these trees. Leslie McQuaide briefly discussed a book by David Dockter Tree Technical Manual. Julie Cockle added that there are trees that don't pose a danger but may still fail, and residents should have a say in what tree species are planted. Amandeep Khurana spoke about a Eucalyptus tree in his front yard dropping limbs 8-12 feet long, posing a danger to Easton children. He stated that the possible damage that falling limbs may cause needs to be considered. Jennifer Pfaff commented about the safety of people in residential areas and believes that the City goes over and above to consider this aspect. She explains that risk is linked to any city that has a tree and that Burlingame has been fortunate to have few incidents, and they did not involve Eucalyptus trees. If you look at the street tree lists, there are no native trees listed because they do not have the qualities we value. Christine Ackerman commented on the staff report presented and that in the 2007 Beautification Commission meeting when the Theme Block decision was established, the Commission anticipated removal and replacement within 20 years, and that time is almost here. She asked how scenarios are being considered when planning for the next six years. A gentleman from the public spoke about the low statistics provided in the staff report of possible danger to people and that the risk is much higher for those residents that live within the vicinity of these large Eucalyptus trees. He believes residents should have a greater say in what happens to City trees and would like to see a more specific timeline and path of action. Eylul Stobaugh stated that she does not feel like she has a voice as someone who lives near a Eucalyptus tree and would like to know what action plan is established, if any. She would also volunteer her time to assist with the planning stage if necessary. Commissioner and Staff Discussion Ensued Arborist Holtz spoke about the 20-year timeframe listed in the 2007 Theme Block decision and confirmed that 11 trees had been removed on Easton Drive and that the City has engaged with an independent arborist. He explained that there have been comments on the severity of consequences that are not the same as the probability and likelihood of failure. If staff knows that a tree has an increased likelihood of failure, staff acts to reduce the likelihood. Actions may not be removal as certain pruning can reduce risk. He confirmed that additional work in Easton, including pruning and removals, will occur and is not the only area. The City will be engaging with an independent contractor to do much of the required work. The framework needs to be established, considering it is expensive work. He explained the bidding process and estimated time frame. He explained that the Theme Block petition staff received will be added to the next meeting. REPORTS Commissioner Khoury reported on the approval to enhance plantings on the west entrance of Burlingame Avenue. She stated that progress was made for the holiday lighting along Broadway and Burlingame Avenue. Further, she thanked Director Glomstad and Arborist Holtz for facilitating the electrical work and tree maintenance on the trees in preparation for the holiday lighting. Commissioner Kirchner stated that he attended the Arbor Day ceremonies and was glad to be back in person and summarized the event. Director Glomstad reported on the start of the TopGolf construction. She stated that the City is coming close to finalizing plans for the Mobility Hub Project in front of the Burlingame Ave. Train Station and provide a brief description of what the project includes. Further, Director Glomstad shared that giant Redwood stumps will be reused to make seating near the front of Washington Park. El 1a111" 45110u 11l►o I There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 7:51 pm. The next Beautification Commission meeting is scheduled for May 4, 2023. Respectfully submitted, Vero VlI Ca 7Flvres Veronica Flores Administrative Staff BU.IRLINGAME STAFF REPORT l{n 11 To: Burlingame Beautification Commission Date: June 1, 2023 From: Richard Holtz, Parks Superintendent/City Arborist Subject: Public Hearing to Consider an Appeal of the City Arborist's Approval of the Removal of Two Protected Private Trees at 1515 Floribunda Ave. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends that the Commission review the City Arborist's decision to approve the removal of two privately protected trees at 1515 Floribunda Ave. A decision from the Commission shall be made to uphold or reject the City Arborist's decision. BACKGROUND On February 9, 2023, the City Arborist was contacted by Nick Popovic from the condominium complex at 1515 Floribunda Ave. regarding private trees on the property. The resident explained that the Condominium Complex Board had decided to remove all trees and landscaping due to plumbing and irrigation conflict with tree roots. The resident was concerned that some of the trees could be of protected size, requiring City permission to remove them. On February 10, 2023, Nick Popovic showed the City Arborist the trees, and the City Arborist observed several protected sized trees. Staff sent an email to the Board and property management company on February 10, 2023, informing them about the City's Protected Tree Permit Program and that there were seven trees of protected size on the property (Exhibit A). No response was received from the Board. The remaining shrubbery and trees that didn't meet the criteria to be a protected size tree were lawfully removed to make way for property repairs and improvements. On March 31, 2023, the Board at 1515 Floribunda Ave. submitted a Private Tree Removal Permit Application to remove a Hemlock and a Juniper tree on the property and a Liquidambar tree in the City planter strip. On April 14, 2023, the Liquidambar tree removal was denied since it is City property and under its maintenance program. The Hemlock and Juniper trees were approved for removal based on the criteria in Chapter 11.06 of the Municipal Code, Urban Reforestation and Tree Protection Ordinance, section 11.06.060, which allows removal for the following reasons: (d) (1) the condition of the tree with respect to the proximity to existing or proposed structures, yards, driveway and other trees... and, (d)(7) the economic consequences and obligations of requiring a tree to remain (Exhibit B). Public notification is required as part of the approval process to remove a private tree that is not dead or being removed under emergency conditions. Residences within one hundred feet of the 1 Appeal of protected Tree Removal at 1515 Floribunda June 1, 2023 applicant's property received a letter (Exhibit B) that stated the reasons the removal was approved and how the decision could be appealed. The notification letter was mailed to required residences and property owners on April 14, 2023. On April 21, 2023, the first of two appeals were received as a result of the public notification process (Exhibit C). DISCUSSION The applicant provided an Arborist report (Exhibit D) supporting their removal reasoning. The City Arborist viewed the Juniper and Hemlock trees and verified the site conditions. The City Arborist agreed with most of the reasoning provided by the Arborist report supporting removal as the best mitigation measure for the trees of concern. Hemlock The Hemlock tree grows on the North-West side of the property. It is located approximately three feet from a public sidewalk and private pathway. Significant surface rooting is evident. The tree has co -dominant leaders (Exhibit E). The union has evidence of included bark. Included bark decreases the strength of the attachment and increases the likelihood of failure of the co -dominant leader at the union. As the tree grows, the likelihood of failure increases over time, and each co - dominant leader's weight and wind load increase. The likelihood could be lessened by "cabling." Cabling is a method of limiting movement and providing additional support to weak or compromised tree parts. This practice requires annual inspection and adjustment and is usually reserved for high -value specimens. The City Arborist believes this situation would not warrant a cabling recommendation as a mitigation measure. The Independent Arborist report also references the location of a natural gas line, and a sewer line seven feet from the tree is presently impacted by root intrusion. For the reasons above, the City Arborist has approved the request of the applicant to remove and replace the tree per the Burlingame Municipal Code. Juniper The Juniper tree grows against a building near the pool. Because of its location, the tree has grown off -balance and away from the building. The specimen has evidence of root infrastructure conflict with the surrounding concrete area (Exhibit F). The Independent Arborist report and application reference concern that the tree is highly flammable. This concern is muted in the urban setting, especially as the adjacent building utilizes stucco siding and is surrounded by concrete and a pool. Of greater concern is the potential root conflict with the structure of the building. Because of the potential future costs associated with structural damage, the City Arborist has approved removing and replacing the Juniper tree per the Burlingame Municipal Code. The applicant has provided the necessary data to support removing and replacing two private trees per the criteria in Burlingame's Municipal Code Chapter 11.06.060. The City Arborist viewed the trees in question and determined removal and replacement as the best mitigation measure for the trees viewed in their present state. EXHIBITS (A) Email to the Property Owner Regarding the Protected Tree Permitting Program (B) City Arborist Removal Approval Letter 2 Appeal of protected Tree Removal at 1515 Floribunda June 1, 2023 (C) Two Appeals Protesting the Removal of Two Protected Trees (D) Arborist Report from Mathey Tree Care (E) Photos of Hemlock tree (F) Photos of Juniper tree 3 EXHIBIT A PARKS/REC-Veronica Flores From: PARKS -Richard Holtz Sent: Friday, February 10, 2023 10:27 AM To: justin.mcsharry@gmail.com; julienirav@gmail.com; greg@3state.net; pm@3state.net Subject: Planned removal of private trees at 1515 Floribunda Importance: High Hello, The Burlingame Parks Division has been contacted by concerned residents of planned tree removals at 1515 Floribunda Ave in Burlingame. They have stated that all landscaping including mature trees will be removed as part of planned Irrigation and landscape improvements. It appears as if at least 7 trees photographed below meet the criteria for requirement of an approved private tree removal permit from the City of Burlingame. The basic definition of a protected tree needing a private tree removal permit is a tree that has a trunk 48" in circumference at a height of 54" above grade. More information can be found HERE. You are hereby on notice that trees meeting this criteria must not be removed without an approved private tree removal permit. Public notification is required. The permit decision approval is at the sole discretion of City staff, Beautification commissioners (on appeal) and City Council (on appeal). Redwood trees that meet the protected status must always have an independent arborist report. Please reach out to me should you have any questions. 16 v 0 f. ._ ---F-- - ja-.-.. \ �� .y . . -� •fir- la. :`t..q�'.5+y"'rt..'.4'. om VA lot r.!jo ''' w 44 i..-41 A "1.1. 1.. I'. .Ic" t 1 44 Awva� Aor b 11- TUESDAY, MARCH 7, 2023 AT 10 AM AT MURRAY FIELD 250 ANZA BLVD, BURLINGAME EXHIBIT B City of Burlingame AOL BURLINGAME Parks & Recreation Department 850 Burlingame Ave., Burlingame, CA 94010 phone: (650) 558-7330 • parksadminkburlin ag me.org April 14, 2023 Floribunda Casistas Inc. HOA C/O Tri-State Enterprises 2133 Leghorn St. Mountain View, CA 940403 RE: Private Tree Removal Application —1515 Floribunda Avenue The application for the removal of a Hemlock tree and a Hollywood Juniper tree has been reviewed and approved. The removal of the City Liquidambar tree is not approved. The Hemlock tree has fair vigor and poor form having co -dominant leaders. The Hollywood Juniper tree has good vigor but remains out of balance due to growth against a building. Property owner and Arborist report state root conflict with sewer infrastructure. It is agreed they are poorly located specimens. Therefore, I am approving removal of these trees based on the criteria in Chapter 11.06 of the Municipal Code, Urban Reforestation and Tree Protection Ordinance, section 11.06.060 which allows removal for the following reasons: (d) (1) the condition of the tree with respect to the proximity to existing or proposed structures, yards, driveway and other trees... and, (d)(7) the economic consequences and obligations of requiring a tree to remain. The Liquidambar is a City asset and responsibility. The tree has been significantly pruned to prevent limb failure from included bark. The tree is routinely monitored and pruned. There is no immediate need to remove this tree. Replacement with TWO 24-inch box standard size single stem landscape trees (no fruit, nut, Japanese Maple, Palm, or Cypress) will be required to be planted anywhere on the private property as defined in Section 11.06.090. Replacement trees must have a mature height of over 15 feet. Adjacent property owner(s) within 100 feet of the property listed above are also receiving notification of this decision. Appeals to this decision or any of its conditions or findings, must be filed in writing to our office by, April28, 2023 as provided in Section 11.06.080 of the Urban Reforestation and Tree Protection Ordinance (Burlingame Municipal Code Chapter 11.06). The permit will be issued at the end of the workday on April 28, 2023, if no appeal has been received by that date. Sincerely, RG�GlY'Gi(vf) Richard Holtz Park Supervisor Certified Arborist WE-8393AM RH/vf CC: Adjacent Property Owners EXHIBIT C PARKS/REC-Veronica Flores From: Nick Popovic <nlpopovic@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, April 20, 2023 7:48 PM To: PARKS -Richard Holtz Cc: Parks Admin Subject: Re: Emailing: Arborist Report Floribunda Casitas, 1515 Floribunda - RH Approval, Appeal request Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged You don't often get email from nlpopovic@gmail.com. Learn why this is important Hello Richard, Thank you for taking the call and sharing related information! Yes, would like to appeal this decision in regards to Juniper tree. Kind regards, Nick On Apr 20, 2023, at 3:50 PM, PARKS -Richard Holtz <rholtz@burlingame.org> wrote: Hello Mr. Popovic, Thank you for taking the time to express your disappointment with my decision to allow the two tree removals proposed for 1515 Floribunda. As discussed, attached are the provided Arborist report and my reasons to approve two of the three trees for removal. Please kindly reply all to this email if you would like to appeal my decision to the Beautification Commission. The next scheduled meeting will occur on Thursday, June 1 at 6:30 PM at the Community Center. Richard J Holtz Parks Superintendent / City Arborist Certified Arborist WE- 8393AM 850 Burlingame Avenue, Burlingame, CA 94010 Office (650) 558-7333 / Cell (650) 759-3126 Please consider the environment before printing this email. Sign up for eNews <Arborist Report Floribunda Casitas.pdf><1515 Floribunda - RH Approval.pdf> This email is from an external source. Please take caution when clicking links or opening attachments. When in doubt, contact your IT Department 1 [Im Ms. Elaine Purvis 15948 S Wilshire Car Oregon City, OR 97045-8309 -,;-;// / /� '7" City of Burlingame BURLINGAME Parks & Recreation Department 850 Burlingame Ave., Burlingame, CA 94010 phone: (650) 558-7330 • parksadmin(aburlin ag me.org April 28, 2023 Nikola Popovic & Ivana Milin 1515 Floribunda Ave #306 Burlingame, CA 94010 Dear Mr. Popovic and Ms. Milin, We are in receipt of your letter regarding your appeal to the approved removal of two private trees, one Hemlock and one Hollywood Juniper tree, at 1515 Floribunda Avenue. Your appeal to the removal of both trees has been forwarded to the Burlingame Beautification Commission, and a hearing will be scheduled for Thursday, June 1, 2023, at 6:30 pm at the Commission's regular meeting. Although the Hemlock has fair vigor, it shows poor form having co -dominant leaders. Further, the Hollywood Juniper tree has good vigor but remains out of balance due to growth against a building. The property owner states root conflict with sewer infrastructure. Please submit any documentation you have in support of retention of the trees to the Parks Administrative Assistant by Monday, May 22, 2023. Your documentation can be sent to the Parks Division office at 850 Burlingame Avenue or by email to parksadmin(a)burlin ag me.org. If you wish to attend the meeting and address the Commission regarding this matter, you can do so in person at the Community Center or via Zoom Commission meeting. The information will be posted on the City website under the Beautification Commission Agenda 72 hours before the June meeting. In addition, the adjacent property owners are being sent a copy of this letter, pursuant to City Ordinance, so they may attend the Commission meeting and make any comments if they wish. If you have any questions, please contact our office at (650) 558-7330. Sincerely, Richard Holtz Parks Supervisor/City Arborist City of Burlingame CC: Adjacent Property owners Floribunda Casitas Inc. HOA C/O Tri-State Enterprises 2133 Leghorn St. Mountain View, CA 94043 LUanIHWI March , 2023 ARBORIST REPORT Page 1 On March 28th, 2023, 1 Rich Mathey, visited 1515 Floribunda Ave, Burlingame CA which is home to the Floribunda Casitas HOA to assess three trees of concern. The three trees observed are 1 Liquidambar, 1 Eastern Hemlock and 1 Hollywood Juniper. All three trees are causing havoc to the infrastructure of the property. The HOA is re landscaping the front and back of the grounds which includes planting of 12 trees. Please consider my observations as noted below: Subject tree #1 — Liquidambar - Liquidambar styraciflua DBH — 22 inches Height — approx 50 feet Canopy Spread — approx 15 feet Health — poor Structural Defects - The Liquidambar is located on the strip between the sidewalk and the street in front of the HOA. The roots have caused the asphalt for the semi circle which accesses the entrance to the HOA to crack, the roots have also raised the sidewalk and the sidewalk elevation is a trip hazard to pedestrians. The past pruning of this tree is non compliant with the ISA Pruning standards - the top of the canopy was topped and all of the larger scaffold branches were cut to stubs. These larger branches should have been reduced to where there is a lateral branch that is at least one third of the diameter of the branch which was being reduced. I have attached pictures to demonstrate the poor condition of the tree and I am recommending removal with stump 4635 Dolores Ave. Oakland, CA 94602 (510) 326-2686 matheytreecare@gmail.com Page 2 grinding of the Liquidambar in poor condition. 4635 Dolores Ave. Oakland, CA 94602 (510) 326-2686 matheytreecare@gmail.com Page 3 Subject tree #2 — Hemlock - Tsuga DBH — 13 inches Height — approx 50 feet Canopy Spread — approx 20 feet Health — Fair Structural Defects - The Hemlock tree has a co dominant trunk with included bark. This union is very weak and as the tree grows there will be a risk of failure of one or both of the trunks. This tree is located 7 feet from the sewer lateral and these roots are currently blocking the sewer pipe and during the heavy rains the drainage is rising to the surface of the ground because of the blockage caused by the Hemlocks roots. The Hemlock is also located within the path of the gas line and over time the roots will damage the gas line. This tree has multiple defects and is considered a tree that is 4635 Dolores Ave. Oakland, CA 94602 (510) 326-2686 matheytreecare@gmail.com Page 4 located in an unsuitable location and my recommendation is for removal and have the roots carefully removed. 4635 Dolores Ave. Oakland, CA 94602 (510) 326-2686 matheytreecare@gmail.com Page 5 Subject tree #3 — Hollywood Juniper - Juniperus chinensis DBH — Multi stem totalling of 48 inches Height — approx 20 feet Canopy Spread — approx 25 feet Health — Fair Structural Defects - The Juniper has multiple trunks and the base of the trunk is located 6 feet from the building's foundation. Junipers are a very flammable species of tree and having a tree located within 10 feet from the structure is considered a fire hazard and I am recommending removal of the tree and removal of all roots. 4635 Dolores Ave. Oakland, CA 94602 (510) 326-2686 matheytreecare@gmail.com Page 7 Although the recommendations in this report are based on sound and accepted horticultural practices, the author cannot be held responsible for the final outcome of the recommendations or any liabilities associated with this project. Tree inspections, in this case, do not cover all internal cavities, condition of the root system nor non -visible structural defects or disease. If you have any questions or require any additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me. You may contact me on my cell phone at (510) 326-2686 or by email at matheytreecare@gmail.com. Thank you in advance for your prompt consideration in this matter. Regards, kicAavd C. MatAey Richard L. Mathey Certified Arborist WI-1084A ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualified 4635 Dolores Ave. Oakland, CA 94602 (510) 326-2686 matheytreecare@gmail.com BU.IRLINGAME STAFF REPORT l{n 11 To: Beautification Commission Date: June 1, 2023 From: Richard Holtz, Parks Superintendent/City Arborist Subject: Consideration of Changing the Themed Block Tree Species for the 1600 - 1700 Blocks of Easton Drive RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends that the Commission review the petition received for the 1600 - 1700 blocks of Easton Drive and consider changing the current Themed Block tree species. BACKGROUND Themed Blocks are street blocks throughout the City designated as one defined tree species as the only tree to replace street trees removed on the Themed Block. The purpose of a Themed Block is to establish a singular species along a designated block to maintain the intended character of the original plantings. However, trees are not removed for the purpose of contributing to a Themed Block designation. Trees are replaced for health, safety, or infrastructure conflict concerns. The process of having every tree on the Themed Block as the designed Themed species can take generations to complete. Themed Blocks can be one block of a street, a couple of blocks of a street, or the full street. The process to have a block(s) designated as a Themed Block follows an application process that the Beautification Commission hears at a public meeting with the final approval from the City Council. The petition form to Apply for the Establishment, Modifying, or Removing a Street Tree Themed Block can be found on the City website under Parks and Recreation, Trees, Online Tree Documents. When street trees are replaced on blocks not designated a Themed Block, the resident or City Arborist (depending on the location) picks the replacement tree from the Approved Street Tree lists. Easton Drive Easton Drive was once the private driveway to the Black Hawk estate owned by the Easton family. Famed Golden Gate Park Landscaper John Maclaren was enlisted to plant the Blue Gums in the 1870s. Many of the trees have been preserved and endured for decades. In 1976, the Easton Drive trees were included in a Heritage Grove designation (Exhibit A). As large Eucalyptus trees were removed, some community members expressed an interest in keeping Easton Drive as a large canopy grove. As a result, the Beautification Commission held 1 Consideration of Themed Block Revision for 1600-1700 Block of Easton Drive June 1, 2023 public meetings to discuss establishing Easton Drive's 1500 - 2000 blocks as Themed Blocks as a long-range plan for Easton Drive (Exhibit B). Some of the meetings that were held included arboriculture experts Larry Costello and David Dockter, offering opinions of Eucalypt species more suitable for the Urban environment. The meetings were publicly noticed and culminated with a community meeting at the Presbyterian Church on June 28, 2007. The final decision was to establish Corymbia Citriodora (Lemon Scented Gum) as the Themed species for this area whenever a tree was replaced. The Lemon Scented Gum was selected because of its shorter stature, less propensity for branch failure, and cleaner presence than its cousin, the Blue Gum. Since 2008, this tree has been planted to replace trees removed on Easton Drive's 1500 - 2000 blocks. The oldest Lemon Scented Gum planted on Easton Drive is located in front of the Easton Library. It was planted in 2008 to replace "Tom the Tree," a large Blue Gum Eucalyptus tree. Lemon Scented Gum The Lemon Scented Gum is a relative of the Eucalyptus tree. Where the Blue Gum specimen can reach heights of over 200 feet tall and has a reputation as a messy tree shedding large barks straps and dropping acorns, the Lemon Scented Gum, in contrast, has a smaller stature reaching a typical height of 75 feet tall in the urban environment. This species does not shed bark straps nor drop large acorns. The tree has been planted in many municipal landscapes, including San Francisco, Santa Monica, and Coronado. The specimen is featured and recommended as a specimen tree in landscapes. It has been found on recommended plant lists by an Australian government agency (Exhibit C). This is due to the tree's ecological benefits, wildlife support, climate adaptability, low-water use, disease resistance, and life expectancy. The tree has also been found on a do not plant list due to invasiveness and branch failure rate (Exhibit D). Another discussion in 2013 stated that arborists have not been able to demonstrate a higher instance of branch failure among Lemon Scented Gums (Exhibit E). The City's experience with this species is limited to plantings along Easton Drive and Burlingame Avenue. Easton Drive Eucalyptus Since the early 2000s, the Easton Drive Eucalyptus trees have experienced an accelerated maintenance program. This includes independent arborist reporting every two years and pruning every three years. The accelerated program aims to identify the potential increased likelihood of failure. Reduction of the likelihood of failure is achieved through pruning and canopy reduction or removal if warranted. The canopy reduction reduces the loading effect of wind to reduce the likelihood of a toppling event. When the risk cannot be mitigated through pruning, whole tree removals are considered. Since the Themed Block was established for Easton Drive, no requests to change the Themed designation have been received by City staff. ni-qr_i i-qcinm 2 Consideration of Themed Block Revision for 1600-1700 Block of Easton Drive June 1, 2023 The significant storms of winter 2023 saw many large tree failures. One large Blue Gum Eucalyptus tree failed, and six others showed significant movement in the soil, indicating an elevated risk for potential failure. Out of an abundance of caution, City staff recommended the evacuation of homes near trees with the perceived elevated risk. As staff met with Easton Drive residents, some expressed concern about living amongst these tall trees. They shared that they did not want the Lemon Scented Gum tree to be the replacement tree. A resident circulated a letter that some residents signed requesting the Beautification Commission's consideration of a shorter, native species that are more sustainable and requires less maintenance. Residents circulated the required petition and received the signatures of 80% of the property owners of the 1600 block of Easton Drive (Exhibit F). The 1700 block of Easton Drive received 88.8% of property owners (Exhibit G). Petitions were also sought from 1500, 1800, 1900, and 2000 blocks of Easton Drive. Only the 1600 - 1700 blocks met the 75% threshold for Themed Block modification. Overall, the sentiment of the property owners is to remove Lemon Scented Gum as the Themed species on all of the Themed Blocks at a rate of 61.5% to modify to a native species, with 32 of 52 property owners signing the petition letter (Exhibits H). Exhibit I shows which property owners signed the petition, noted in yellow. The properties noted in red either didn't sign the petition or could not be verified as the property owner based on the County property records search. The Commission has several options to consider below. However, though the petition only met the threshold to consider changing the Theme on the 1600 - 1700 blocks, the entirety of the 1500 - 2000 block corridor should be reviewed due to the grove's heritage designation, reforestation plan for the area, and petition statement. In addition, the Commission should consider how possible species will interact with overhead conductors on the south side of Easton Drive. Reject the Petition By rejecting the petition, the Lemon Scented Gum will remain the Themed Block species for the 1600-1700 blocks of Easton Drive. The basis for this decision could include that significant community outreach occurred in 2007. Industry experts and staff invested considerable time in developing a long-range reforestation plan for Easton Drive to create a sustainable grove that embraced the history and uniqueness of Easton Drive for generations to enjoy. By selecting the Lemon Scented Gum, it addressed the community concerns regarding debris produced and the height of mature trees. Modify the Existing Long -Range Reforestation Plan for the 1600 - 1700 Blocks of Easton Drive Recognizing a shift in neighborhood demographics and desires, the Commission could change the existing Themed of Lemon -Scented Gum. The options include: 1. The Commission could select a new Themed species on the 1600 - 1700 blocks of Easton Drive. 2. The Commission could include additional tree options on an Easton Drive -specific Street Tree list, allowing property owners or the City Arborist to select replacement trees from a narrow list. This option may or may not include the Lemon Scented Gum. 3 Consideration of Themed Block Revision for 1600-1700 Block of Easton Drive June 1, 2023 Because the planter strips on this part of Easton Drive were kept very wide to accommodate the large Eucalyptus trees, large trees should be considered due to a lessened likelihood of infrastructure conflict and the greater benefits large trees provide to the community. Examples of some potential tree species to consider are below. Species Common Name Height CA Native Evergreen Calocedrus decurrens Incense cedar 100'+ Yes Yes Cinamomum camphora Camphor tree 40-60' No- East Asia Yes Corymbia citriodora Lemon Scented Gum 60-100' No -Australia Yes Quercus agrifolia Coast Live Oak 40-80' Yes- CA Coast Yes Quercus lobata Valley Oak 70-100' Yes- CA Valley No Quercus suber Cork Oak 30-50' No- Mediterranean Yes Sequoia sempervirens Coastal Redwood 100'+ Yes- CA Coast Yes Ulmus' Patriot' Patriot Elm 50-80' No No Remove Themed Block Designation The 1600 — 1700 blocks of Easton Drive would no longer be a Themed with the Lemon Scented Gum, and the property owner or City Arborist would choose a replacement tree from the Street Tree list for planter strips widths over 6' (Exhibit J). Request Additional Information To help in the decision -making process, the Commission could require additional information. If this is the case, the Commission can table the item until the additional information is ready for the Commission's review at a future regularly scheduled Commission meeting date. EXHIBITS A. Easton Drive Heritage Grove Designation 1976 B. Long -Range Reforestation Plan for Easton Drive C. Lemon Gum Recommendation (Australia) D. Lemon Gum Do Not Plant List (Australia) E. Lemon Gum Branch Failure Rate Discussion (Australia) F. Petition Letter 1600 Block of Easton Drive G. Petition Letter 1700 Block of Easton Drive H. 1500 - 2000 Block Easton Drive Signature List I. 1500 - 2000 Block Easton Drive Map J. Trees to Be Planted in Areas 6' Wide and Over :ITY OF BURLINGAME EXHIBIT PARK DEPARTMENT HERITAGE GROVE DESIGNATION Date—., Apri 1 1 , 1976 NOtMINATI O ! FOR HERITAGE TREE STATUS IS HEREBY HADE BY : Name 1) Mr. Joseph E.. Harvey, 2205 Adeline Dr. .,Burl ingame.CA Phone:3446210 2)Park Director John Hoffman, City Hall, Burlingame, CA Phone:342-893' (City) Sate (Lip) FOR THE FvLLUtIif,G Common Frame Eucalyptus, Pine, Cypress, Other Srecies Botanical Name Located *M on Easton Drive, from El Camino Real to Vancouver Avenue, Burlingame, Cal fornia 94010: All trees on the street_right-of -way. Owned by the City of Burlingame, 501 Primrose Rd.. Burlingame, CA QUALIFICATIONS OF THE GROVE Historic Significance_ Planted by early land owners 4 Planted by John McLaren Date of Planting 1870's Age 100 vears Character Impressive avenue of giant trees Beauty Massive trunks, tall imposing trees _ Rarity Most species in grove not rare , some are uncommon -_ Other -Special Characteristics Some of largest eucalypti and cypress in Burlingame. Monterey Cypress ra e,, -I U 11 C irc:=--4Y1'9 am. " _ " Diam. Signed by:- / {fSig L of I,0" r.ator� Approved by Owner of Tree:t Signature �•ir�er �epresentati ve BEAUTIFICATION COMMISSION REVIEW The Commission reviewed the notainatlon and made the following recommendation: Approval [✓1 Disapproval [ 1 rIature_ jate) CITY COUNCIL DESIGNATIO,.: r tderitage Status [v� No Heritage Status [ � ic3nature �(-Uate�}�. EXHIBIT B %� Beautification Commission Meeting Community Forum Long Range Reforestation for Easton Drive June 28, 2007 @ 7:00 pm First Presbyterian Church —1500 Easton Drive Commissioners Present: McQuaide, Benson, and Ellis Absent: Carney, Grandcolas, Wright Excused: Lahey Staff: Director Schwartz, Superintendent Richmond, Supervisor Disco, Secretary Harvey Audience: Jennifer Pfaff (615 Bayswater Avenue); Joann and Peter Garrison (2905 Adeline Drive); Jean Silveira (2331 Poppy Drive); Hing & Lillian Dear (1911 Easton Drive); Mike Bohnert (1201 Carmelita Avenue); Steve Warden (736 Acacia Drive); Jay Martin (1340 Bernal Avenue); Laurie Livingston (1285 Cabrillo Avenue); Kris Cannon (1304 Bernal Avenue); Susie and Sam Leahy (1719 Easton Drive); Augustine Chou (City Hall); Russ Cohen (City Hall); Terry Nagel (City Hall). Welcome and Introductions Chairperson McQuaide welcomed and thanked everyone for coming. Chairperson McQuaide stated that, based on comments at the first forum a consensus was reached to keep the same look or character of the neighborhood by replacing with a Eucalyptus variety that had wind stability, had little or no fruit, but would grove from 60 to 80', having a similar trunk girth to the existing Blue Gums. She explained that at the last forum, three Eucalyptus species were selected as possible replacements, the Sugar Gum Eucalyptus as primary tree, the Eucalyptus Nicolii as corner trees, and the Eucalyptus ficifolia as the replacement tree when the tree in front of the library was to be removed. Since that time, it has been realized that the Eucalyptus ficifolia drops flowers and has large fruit, and though the Sugar Gum Eucalyptus is beautiful, it is only available in the United Kingdom; no suppliers grow them, but that the Eucalyptus Nicolii variety, favored as corner trees, is readily available. Chairperson McQuaide continued that tonight's forum will focus on affirming a Eucalyptus specie as the replacement tree on Easton Drive, and if affirmed, selecting and reaching consensus as to which readily available Eucalyptus specie(s) would be used as the primary tree and what if any would be used as corner trees, and the replacement for the tree fronting the Easton Branch Library. She concluded that staff will present pictures of Eucalyptus species for consideration and that consensus reached at this meeting will be further discussed at the Beautification Commission meeting of August 2nd. A recommendation from the Commission will be forwarded to the City Council. Director Schwartz introduced new commissioner, Bobbi Benson, and Commissioner Ellis, and noted that Commissioner Susie Lahey, would not be participating as a Commissioner but is attending the meeting and in the audience observing as an interested homeowner on Easton Drive. Director Schwartz also introduced Parks Division staff: Superintendent Richmond, Supervisor Disco, and Secretary Harvey; and Public Works engineer Augustine Chou, and representatives from the Traffic, Safety, and Parking Commission, Steve Warden and Mike Bohnert. Community Forum and Discussion — Easton Drive Tree Selection Director Schwartz noted that replacements of the Eucalyptus trees will occur gradually happening over the next 20 years as existing trees require removal. He explained that since the last forum it has been suggested that perhaps other tree species (such as Redwoods and Elms) be considered as replacement trees on Easton Drive. Director Schwartz then asked for input from the audience on the specie selection. The discussion included some continents and concerns with regard to: Planting locations on Easton Drive; planting in empty planting sites; parking concerns; El Camino Real Eucalyptus tree removal and replacements with Elms; City policy that trees are planted in vacant sites only if approved by the property owner; watering/maintenance practices of City trees, etc. Additional comments from the audience were: If the Easton Drive Eucalyptus need removing, they should be replaced with a Eucalyptus specie, otherwise Easton Drive would not be the same; an important and majestic grove of trees should only be replaced with the same variety of tree; and that some streets, like Easton Drive, warrant larger trees and a uniform selection because of the historic significance of the street (entrance to an estate). Following the discussion, Director Schwartz asked for a "thumbs up" consensus affirming that the Eucalyptus specie be the favored replacement tree on Easton Drive. Consensus was reached affirming that only the Eucalyptus specie be considered as the replacement tree for Easton Drive and there were no contrary comments. Superintendent Richmond then presented pictures of several Eucalyptus species: Eucalyptus Citriodora (readily available), Eucalyptus Nicoll] (readily available), and the Eucalyptus Saligna (contract grown only). Supervisor Disco noted that the existing Eucalyptus Globulus is not available, and he does not believe the next closest to that, the Sidney Blue Gum, is readily available. He noted that because the Easton Drive Eu.cs will be removed one by one, as necessary, contract growing can only be considered for growing a larger quantity of trees. Commissioner Warden stated that several more trees may also need removing and replacing in the near future; Councilmember Cohen clarified that if the intent is reforestation, then planting in the existing vacant planting sites as well as any projected removal sites, might be enough to consider contract growing. Supervisor Disco agreed, but that it would depend on the minimum number of plants the contractor would be willing to grow, and the resulting cost. Director Schwartz asked for audience discussion and input. Some comments from the audience included: Planting in city -owned planter strips used for parking; residents willingness to "give up" parking places; planting with the Iron Bark Eucalyptus on the corners; keeping the same variety on both sides of the street; and consideration of putting a planter strip down the center of Easton Drive. Superintendent Richmond noted that at the previous forum expert David Docktor presented a list of 3 large alternatives to the Blue Gum: the Sugar Gum or Cladocalyx is not readily available, and the Sidney Blue Gum can be contract grown from seed or the City can purchase a minimum of 1000 seedlings at a cost of $1000. This requires space to grow 1.000 seedlings, and the man power to care for the seedlings. Superintendent Richmond noted, however, that the Eucalyptus Citriodora 'Lemon Scented Gum', with copper colorations in the trunk, thin bark, broad canopy, with growth to 1.00' is readily available. He noted that one will soon be planted in front of the Burlingame Recreation Center. Supervisor Disco stated that the girth of the trunk is approximately 90", the debris from trunk is virtually non existent, the tree has small fruit, and a grove of this specie Eucalyptus exists in the City of Palo Alto. Chairperson McQuaide noted that the Eucalyptus Citriodora meets the desired characteristics: wind tolerant, frost tolerant, fast growing, height but it has a smaller trunk girth than the Blue Gum or Sydney Blue Gum. 2 Community Forum and Discussion — Easton Drive Tree Selection — (Contd.) Following the discussion, Director Schwartz stated that staff s recommendation is for the Eucalyptus Citriodora to be planted as the primary replacement tree on Easton Drive and asked the audience for a "thumbs up" consensus of that recommendation. Consensus was reached to plant the Eucalyptus Citriodora as the primary replacement tree and there were no contrary comments. Supervisor Disco then presented pictures and commented on the accent trees previously considered for use on corners and in front of the Easton Branch Library if the existing Eucalyptus tree is removed: 1) Eucalyptus Nicolii — Grows to 50', has very narrow leaves; lacey and soft looking, bark is rough and does not shed. Supt. Richmond noted that this specie is readily available and Chairperson McQuaide added this tree would allow for better visibility on the corners. 2) Eucalyptus ficifolia — Grows to approximately 50% showy red flowers that drop off with large seed capsules. The tree also drips nectar. Some comments and concerns from the audience were as follows: All the trees on Easton Drive should be the same; corner trees should be repositioned when planted with traffic visibility taken into account; all the trees should be the same, no accent trees, and the corner trees should be planted at a safe distance from the corner; and planting something different, and something with flowers, would detract from the fabulous renovation to the Easton Branch Library; the same tree should be planted all along Easton Drive; where are accent trees going to be planted?; how far from the corners? (PW would be consulted); why would you plant accent trees on an avenue with grand trees? Following the comments and discussion, Director Schwartz asked for a "thumbs up" consensus of planting the same specie Eucalyptus, all along Easton Drive, including the corners and in front of the Easton Branch Library. Consensus was reached to have no corner or "accent" trees and there were no contrary comments. Director Schwartz summarized the conclusions of the forum to be discussed at the next Beautification Commission meeting of August 2" d: 1) Eucalyptus to be the only tree genus to be considered as suitable for Easton Drive tree replacement. 2) The favored Eucalyptus specie to be considered is the readily available Eucalyptus Citriodora. 3) That there be no corner or "accent" trees; Eucalyptus Citriodora be the sole replacement tree all along the lower Easton Drive. Director Schwartz noted that Traffic, Safety, and Parking Commission will meet in Council Chambers on July 12`i' at 7:00 pm and will be discussing the Easton Drive tree replacement and making recommendation to the Council. The Beautification Commission will be meeting in City Hall's Conference Room "A" on August 2nd at 5:30pm, and will be discussing the Easton Drive tree replacement plan and making a recommendation to Council. 3 Community Forum and Discussion — Easton Drive Tree Selection — (Contd.) Some closing comments from the audience were: Promote the restoration of Easton Drive and try to get people interested and enthusiastic about having a new Eucalyptus tree planted in vacant planting sites fronting their homes; on streets that have historical value, the City should approve the planting of larger canopy trees; try to identify and report on trees that have been removed in the past and try to determine what the reasons are for the empty spaces. Chairperson McQuaide thanked everyone for their input and reminded everyone to attend the upcoming Traffic, Safety and Parking Commission and Beautification Commission meetings. There being no further comments, the meeting was adjourned at 8:50 pm. Respectfully submitted, l f�.... �LWes— / Karlene Harvey Recording Secretary 2 5/23/23, 12:30 PM Lemon -scented Gum EXHIBIT, C E2 R �yy 6 y4 U Home. > Living in Merri-bek > Environment > Trees > Corymbia citriodora Lemon -scented Gum Narrow open medium to large, graceful tree to 20-25m. The trunk is smooth grey to white and the foliage smells strongly of lemon when crushed. ©M. Fagg, 2012 I.G. Holliday, ©Australian National Botanical Gardens, 1997 https://www.merri-bek.vic.gov.aulliving-in-merri-beklenvironmentltreesltree-finderlcorymbia-citriodora/ 1/4 5/23/23, 12:30 PM Lemon -scented Gum Details Tree locations and purpose Front or back garden Yes Driveway No Narrow space No Courtyard No Screening No Canopy for shading Yes Planter box with irrigation No Water Sensitive Urban Design (WSUD) No Star rating* The star rating is based on a tree's environmental value, ecological benefits, pest and disease susceptibility, climate change adaptability, life expectancy and amenity value. We recommend you select the right tree for your space, but when you have more than one tree to choose from, select the tree with the highest star rating. This tree is on Council's list of recommended species for planting in Merri- bek. We recommend you choose the right tree for your space, but when you have more than one tree to choose from, select the tree with the highest star rating. The Tree Finder tool is one way Council is working to increase tree canopy across Merri-bek. https://www.merri-bek.vic.gov.aulliving-in-merri-beklenvironmentttrees/tree-finderlcorymbia-citriodoral 2/4 EXHIBIT D Department of Education At% ii Potential HAZARD 14 trees Contents Lemon -scented Gum (Corymbia citriodora) 4 Rose Gum (Eucalyptus grandis) 5 Spotted Gum (Corymbia maculata) 6 Sugar Gum (Eucalyptus cladocalyx) 7 Swamp Mahogany (Eucalyptus robusta) 8 Tasmanian Blue Gum (Eucalyptus globulus) 9 River Red Gum (Eucalyptus camaldulensis) 10 Cape Lilac (Melia azadarach) 11 Bangalay (Eucalyptus botryoides) 12 Marri (Corymbia calophylla) 13 Jarrah (Eucalyptus marginata) 14 Fig (Ficus spp.) 15 Peppermint (Agonis flexuosa) 16 Tuart (Eucalyptus gomphocephala) 17 Pride of Bolivia (Tipuana Tipu) 18 General Trees of Concern 19 TrPPQ et�itahlP fnr cr.hnnlc 7fl Corymbia citriodora (Lemon -scented gum) The lemon -scented gum is a tall tree to 35m that is very popular for its bark colour, gracefulness and its strongly lemon -scented foliage. In structure and appearance it is similar to maculeda, however it is usually distin- guished by its powerful scent and the white/yellow colour of its smooth bark in the warmer months. Like maculata, it has the propensity to shed lug ,heavy limbs when stressed. 5/23/23, 12:31 PM City Council looks to scrap some lemon scented gum from Victoria Square upgrade I The Advertiser EXHIBIT E ndverT. <.emetit TheAdvertiser ��t ��W : sign In Adelaide Today 9 °J 2©° � * My Today's Local SA National World Opinion Business Entertainment Lifestyle Sport Q News Paper News City Council looks to scrap some lemon scented gum from Victoria Square upgrade Messenger City: THE City Council is set to back away from plans to plant only lemon scented gums in Victoria Square. Tim Williams Q less than 2 min read March 19, 2013-3:iopr i City Messenger Q 1 comments News Don't miss out on the headlines from News. Followed categories will be added to My News. Follow THE City Council is set to back away from plans to plant only lemon scented gums in Victoria Square, following complaints about the risk of the natives dropping limbs. Council staff are now proposing to plant 28 plane trees in rows either side of the planned event lawn in the northern half of the square, as part of its multi -million dollar upgrade. Councillors will consider the change tonight. More than 70 lemon scented gums would still be planted elsewhere in the square and the council insists they do not pose a higher safety risk than other species. But a council report does say the risk posed by trees around the event lawn is higher because people are more likely to sit under them than trees closer to the edge of the square. httns'//wwwarielaidennwcnmau/Haws/snufh-australia/city-cniincil_Innkc_in_ccran_cnma_lamnn_ccantari_niim_from_victoria_cniinra-iinnraria/nQ1Ar ctn 1/ I1A 5/23/23, 12:31 PM City Council looks to scrap some lemon scented gum from Victoria Square upgrade I The Advertiser The report says the council has received several complaints about the choice of gums for the event lawn because they were "notorious for dropping limbs for no apparent reason and pose a safety hazard to the public". "Others have stated that gum trees are messy and unattractive and therefore not appropriate for planting in the square." The report says the council has consulted with local and interstate arborists and concluded there is "no scientific evidence" that lemon scented gums drop limbs more than other species, despite "anecdotal evidence and widespread public perception". Lord Mayor Stephen Yarwood had previously supported the plan for exclusively planting natives to give the square a uniform look. But this week he said: "I'm not fussed what trees we have as long as we have as many as possible. "Any trees will be managed with significant care, which does minimise that risk." The report says falling limbs are a public safety risk with the potential to cause "asset damage, personal injury and/or death". Risk would be minimised by planting healthy, structurally sound nursery stock, planting trees close together to reduce the size of their canopies and the weight of spreading branches, watering them in summer and expert pruning. The plane trees would provide a "good design contrast" to the gums and "visually link with the plane trees along King William St", the report says. For more news on the city, pick up a copy of the City Messenger, read our digital edition online, or become a fan of our Facebook page. Join the conversation i 1 corm Heart Surgeon Begs Americans: "Stop Doing This To Your Fruit" Gundry MD 'F**k off, Mary': R-rated row mars city budget debate Dermatologist: If You Have Toenail Fungus Try This Tonight (It's Genius!) httnc-/AA—Afa PI;4idQnnwenm an/nPimQknirth-anctraliaMity_enunril_Innke_to_crran_enmo_lamnn_cronferl_nnm_from_tint—in-c- aro_i9/d EXHIBIT F 1613 -> Easton City of Burlingame Petition to Apply for Establishment, Modify or Remove a Street Tree Themed Block (Only this form can be used to gather signatures) Definition of a Street Tree Themed Block: A street tree themed block is defined as a block in which one defined species of street tree is established and ill, indelinilely. t)nce a lhe►ne<I block is established ,ln(I fI tree is removed for any reason, the tree would be replaced with a tree of the established theme species. The licuulilication ('ollliltission and City Council use the following criteria when considering eslablish111ent ofa thellled block: the hcrcellt ol,l)rl'(I(1I11ill,,,II Iree species, health and disease tolerance of the Species, amount 01.tree diversity, nlix ofspccies, age, acsihctic look on the block, current tree canopy, future canopy potential, width Of the street, and the width of planter strips. Policy to Establish, Modify or Remove a Therned Block • The Beautification commission will recommend "I'llellled Blocks" to the City Council. • To petition the Beautification Commission fur a new Illellled block a property owner on a block shall gather signatures of at least 213 ofthe property owners on the block. • To petition the Beautification Comnlissio►l to modify a specific themed block tree species or Remove a specific block from the Themed Block List, a property owner on a block shall gather signatures of at least 75% of the property owners on the block. • Fornis for the "Petition" will be provided by the Parks and Recreation Department office. • Petitions shall be forwarded to the Beautification Commission for recommendation to the Council to establish, modify or remove a themed block. • A public hearing will be set by the Beautification Commission and notification will be sent by staff to all property owners on the block. • If approved by the Beautification Commission and/or the City Council, staff will determine the species theme in collaboration with the property owners. • Selected "themed" species will replace existing trees only when removal of an existing tree is deemed necessary according to City policy. Street and Block Requested for Consideration: —L. A-�,-To N Dt-I v C — 16 0 t 1 Mark One: Establish Modify V" Remove a Themed Bock Street Tree Species Desired: Street Tree Themed Block Signature Form Property Owner Statement: I am the property owner at the address listed below and I support the Beautification Commission and City Council in establishing this block as a Street Tree Themed Block, modifying this themed block Street Tree or removing this themed block Street Tree within the City of Burlingame. Revised 1/2016 Date Property Address Property Owner Name(s) (Printed) Property Owner Signature 3► � I b o b �� 5 7� N �+2 M A rt 1-�CCP K-t-A u 9, A-N --+ 311-71 IGI& Ea .im ter- —j4'n M m+ Ha*hruj W01 le—j-1(715Cain Drive and Debby e �cFS (►�� , b ice' t f �ll� �L-- try p ,— DeL,1, c� YD� d I t 1604 Easton Drive - Carolyne Ross & Ross Trust City of Burlingame Petition to Apply for Establishment_ Modify or Remove a Street Tree Them*d Block (Only this form can be used to gather signatures) Definition of a dtreet Tree Thorned Blocs > rum trcx tbmwj b xi is dcfmd ar, a SmA let +rl►rti t;lw iicfttaetd "Ci 4- ri �trt-t t itf c t= %' %U (ta1W4 XW tr1jI1I1-Jlttc.l 11% Ilfll'4 k, (Wc a b&'.� 1146VA111111blillied And SOW IS" 46 a+ t7ttlet11 or w'w w'MW be rrfvLxtd witb a trot: (if list: r"hijawA tf,ea+r 4+Mx' itr 11MEACA"" (owaiv%um aft! Cir,l ti tmKd ww tk b>Eilwieittt exitrria rt4tcrt cunttideting erNfhtlaturw�rn c,1 r t1leviod hkc� t3tc percx� 1�f'ttrtlduaoiitttaa sct �� `eal11 ad tfirranit tillrratwe ai` d1e +1w". smaw t of tree (llvesrnhr. mils 1.1 41mW%. ap acwtbntc kit* (a tit (Meld(. cterttcwt (tree coup}. fin teet cos T-1 ptx>nietioat. +1 111 ,4 (lit tnt. and 8tr width of ff1&VC► strip►. Polity to Estabfth, Modify or Remove a Themed Block • Ihr IsCAUtIita11191 ( flttlllilhfOifti #*III %:4,4111tIr2CTid I IKCITIDJ lt}KI(tL�� 11) Attu? t r.ttataT. • If, pollim tau I icaul I fit.410ft (AIt►U1114 61'In Ifw a m-% thc-� N mlk a pnVcm t-ww as a linci ittafl Plkr +iprrAtrat tot' 11 tca%t 2 1 %it the flroWn) fiuik-m tin tl,c hl,Kt • I fI rMilltsi tiu• Itcautificaltlrn Ccitmitwon w rnodef% a 4kroJic ttacmrrd ((flop em Wucie+ Or PUC=L'%C a 41"tIrw 1111" k M411 tlk llwtncd ItltKk 1 W, a prgp► ny ewvoer Iles a hkwk JW1 utter sillpow ten td a bm% 7!Me t$ the t* 4vm i-nen on oltr hif It k • 1 nnn, I1lr tlsc " lloilim' %ill he rwM&d to the I'A-A wW itcctzatrn i)CIM wait ofrtcc. • 1'r11111im Nttall he tnrwarded to the ltcatnofica►i(in t (wtvrtivwm frw to the Utlaweil k1 e.taWkk fmldity tw rctl w a liwilwd h1f K k • A ruhlit hcarilil! -At ll 1x wi hs the iteauitficililen( tmrmiv%wn air! rwrli'wt dviv i will tv %cvt 11* %UIT w AI Mir4c t7 tivrnncm fttt the hlfltk. • It approved by the lk-aunlitatimi ( tgw1I1%%i11n eta! Iw OK t. ity t tail. wIT will tlelcrtrlm• the t11lCtt`c tti ITIC in t f llial oirwinu tt ilh the pit rK7l% owner% • Belched ' ihruii-d ' 6-lint ►r. H ill rrrlatc cot%title, truc% Ilnh #*hen rcnl,nai (►f an exi%twt trre . deemed ncEc-%.ary att,w%l► it to ( ity luilicN Streetl and Mock Requested for Consideration 11090 CAS won+ Mark One L• stablish Modify ✓ Remove a Thorned Sock Street Tree Species Desired Street Tice Thomed Block Signature Form property Owner Statement I am the ototktty owner at the a0drvu hated below and I soappoet VW 8eaUNCO oet Commission and City Council in estabtishmp this otoc-s as a Street Tree Therm stook 1, Ml+;i t!u tteemea block Street Tree or �removing this themed block Street Tree wow. I* City of sudw%garne eon•ed Date Property Address Property owner Nanws) (Prwitea) Property Owner 5ignatut• ILC -- - � EXHIBIT G City of Burlingame Petition to Apply for Establishment. Modify or Remove a Street Tree Themod Block (Only this form can be used to gather siyrfatures) Definition of a Street Tree Themed Block: A ir:kt Irk.0 themed block 1% dclineel as a block in which olio defin•d spel cs of street tree is established , , I n:.unl.uned indctinilcly Once a themcd block is estabhshed and a tree is remoscd for any reason. the tree ►could he replaced ►►ith .i tree of the cst'iblishcd theme species the Ilcautification ( onwus,lot and Cily Council use the lulloicln- criteria ►►hen considering establishment of a ilicined block the pcncm of predominant tree species. he.11th .Ind disease tolerance of the %peetes. aniolint of tree di%crslty, inlx of spcc'les, age. icstliclic look till the block. Current tree -artopy. luture c.jnopy potential. ►►Iddl of the .trees. and the ►%idih of pl.inter strips Policy to Establish, Modify or Remove a Themed Block • 1 h, Il—iwuic,,lum ( onln,i.,lon t►tll rcunnniciid Ihenled Mock:'to the City Council. • 1 o petition the Ilcautili:alion Commission for a lie►► thenied block a property owner on it block shall gailier signatures of at least , 3 of rile property kmnen on the block • lot painon the lle.nitificauon Conunission to modil\ ;t specific thorned hlock tree species of Renito►e a specific block Irout the I heincd Illock I isi, a property owner on a block shill balder signatiires of at least 75% of the property uwncrs on the block • I onns for the "Petition" ►►ill he pro►ided by the (',irks and Rct rcation Wpartment office. • Petition,, shall he lirr%%arded to the licautitication Commission for recommendation to the Council to establish. modily or renro►c a themed block. • A public hearing will he set by the Itcautilication Commission and notilication will he sent by %tiff to all property owners on the hick • II' approved by the Beautification Commission and or the City Council, stall' ►rill doennine the species theme in collaboration ►sith the property owners • '— looted"theined" species will replace existing trees only ►►heft rcinmal of an existing tree is deemed nccessany according to C try policy Street and Block Requested for Consideration (7 OO fc7 oN Pt",ark One Establish Modify Remove a Themed Bock St!eet Tree Species Desired Street Tree Themed Block Signature Form Property Owner Statement I am the property owner at the address listed oeilow and I support the Bmoeautification Commission and City Councii in establishing this block as a Street Tree Themed Block ✓ difying this themed block Street Tree or removing this themed block Street Tree within the City of Burlingame Revised 1;20,16 S r' .� �.t �•c,t�t A-clt �.o/ a'� '�� .�c.G`" �,� Et`2. �-t`� �� o-t� . To: Burlingame Parks and Rec Uepattnaent. Billlin(t;ime Beautification Conumssion, Rialin(Innio City Coun(al Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, btirlingarnr;. Thr: winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, will) one causing darnagn to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We behove these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and welter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots rnust dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. ST U Name Street Number Signature .„ttljs-+!;;r;vr.sar!r•on"�yhno•f,r:n•r.'�rmMrnam'nt�elllra••gr�{ ir�yutuaeur+IylNis-Ira r+nt.rf;ln111f1 I:U(,S /Nrv;v; aribr) 'lov /9rlmer-s-70 i (i/coryu,N.I-I.dru'd',r;Lhtn d "'I lU}'U+yl7L f)jH-;JIh-It Wj 7ov11 rh,;I hpn r,J I Al, A r);jtoi ri, fl,b 1,1. jyn 11)r•rWflI(141i'If IN/Ir•iln_l?"(?Ily l•I,�_•I tIs�SN I.-n (�I ti l" hit; "lil,�y r- h ■ lip I;urlint1ame t'arks and Iles OvImitment, Huilincl,mie L)r'aulifu;ation Conunissum, Ilurhn(Imno (;ily Crnurr.il tear SIr;Madam, phis letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyphrs trees as the chosen species for Easlon Drive, fturhngrune; Th(! Winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing caul rge to a house and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and w(rUer winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees slay smaller and their root rnu ;t dive deep in order to survive In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients' The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fasi2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name r r Signat e 1 Street Number vr,. ,ir.�,,;P•,,�,1, _ n�ir�4br <rr.n� Oq,rtr��u d rru tr r -f Im pit hhn . r' :a .V wT. �.D, .ih,,,i q .r .y.,ir„u � r: i '�b•.I '.i �r f.r N�UIU`di.'� it 4,•�L 1. ' 1 hJ•f.' 14.- ',rt r �� u r. i„- cr,�,. 10 t1urlmktame Palks and Rec Pepartment, Rullinganie Beautification Commission, fturlutci.rrne City Crninr;il bear 5itiMadam. This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingarne the winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a hotisr� and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme - The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. T � � J/ YYY Name — Street Number Signature Ld il�__L'_.�.I�__'1-1r�i n. 0 To: Burlingame Parks and Rec Department, Burlingame Beautification Commission, Burlingame City Council Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warn, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and welter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the Flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. C /fit- V'°t )( Name V ' Si ure \'lam %G S' "Y-t N)V Street Number 1hilr;IN,. nnaardrnm'jenonhou:oinlrjrnarrFnlall rr-r- f,eur�:71y us7r-y1, )lu -re--f �am2nP��1..� % hnns flr+ar:r anbo ar;v atilonpltrninees •Lp1Gfr.,n• rnlr�,,-rnnr,dr;ra Im,l 'nt'[s'lrr::rrrar'rniF•nt+:arc•vardputihraorns/!ahr-fo�rrsnr'.I,,Ll;iypJirrf4Q1U6ri3r(fl%4r:drr•'321hr1•1�1.1R?`iAt lrtttll/hIt II.'tn-..,.1r,,!I To: Burlingame Parks and lim, Deparhnent, Burlingame Beautification Commission, Burlingame City Counrll Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay srnaller and their roots roust dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. c :�dhh �o\ us - l'��a, R_s 0 Name Street Number Signature 'I:nn�.11Vryrvr r�;u•!e,auL�rprrrhovr rnrn/]�17;JL]S;i]lirallf�S:5lL t1S.i11YLtSlirWl;illYLlLL:LL'L.1L�Lt�.itSWilJti.tltla fdar,� llvvuar0), 'jov;in/,I )I llnrnrr.>, MIfili nryndna � ilipulnr�r_Idlnl 'hllo;alrP/rW n%nh��rlwut. W,f nV,nrf �u � u:rlu n.;/Gd, nil Id oars I I,: r. r, ,ri!• it lfl�h, 1� Ir V� r•,I I�Ih I_{il t !i _I,��•f a4` 'h I : tihi,• i' 'J LLl _t-.L_L�..lE�.11•SYL1L__t_�_ t_..___ � __i_i__. lu-� o.t n,_I III l ulling, ulit- I'alks and Rec I1c'I1,111111C11t, I111111111ganle Ileautlficalion Cornnrlssron, Ilurlingarne City Got nr,il Peal Su:Aladam, 1 Ills letter Is Io request you to reconsider l=ucalyphls trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame, Thc. wmtel storms In Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnage to a house and vehicle. 1110 damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and w-titer winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots roust dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. r l�l Sh"i-,I-- t DIV( _ Name Street Number Signature -- — I, /,,If 'uro-a tnl/I I, -, 1.-1 :11yI du siy I I I Imr• I u,i ii• IIIIJ I, Y. i„r s/C�l,lr-�Ilru•�I •. m.1/�,I�.iL,-r •fU lUr• �Irlrf /•I. �Jri• I' Ih 61' I�lR",'il� r1, _I .1 ,_._ --- __-' To: l3ullrlattanar Parks and 11ec Peparlmoill, 111mlingonun Heautlficnlion Cornrru siorr, f1urlui9mrie City Council Dom Sir/Madam, 1-111s letter is to request you to lecunsider lucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, f3urlingarne The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. L=ucalpptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots roust dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallUN root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" IisP. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. %I Name Street Number Signature ,..,. � : , ,..�,_ ..I -r,.,, .r _r., LI ,� rrrnrgrnan•;-rlaUtrrrsh�urnlylrhls/eur�IynUis�ire•e-mob�i;xnrni,� h m c-lf)Ir"ifjVjijiy f'ilmirinra f'i11j}I c• ,i ,v. aJ,..ilgns�I;iLIcrII-:R;,.•r:,n•,I/dra�la'iParr•r/4UIIlrn 1c.1t1/audcc•-t.'llabl, li .-I. I':---__.._ To: BL1111ngame Paiks and f.ec Depallmenl, flurlingame Heaulificalion COMMISS1011, Burlingarne City Council Dear Sn/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus bees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not pallicularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fastz (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Signature d �_ (,) Street Number :: :•: 1a, 1'.. I;yr.,v:l r,v: �q,n/I,rn:vnr-nIII/I, ,c�.h�i, I IyI)l ut.ler u� o lvr l u;-IrI. I nn, I,:� hl,n I %v 'i 111r lnny'JJl!_1-r�tj uj r I r f ;a Illn',I '!,rs/„,::/ r-„?,, ,-, r,;, r., u;I; .i!,I,r .,t,yr, al:, 1;!,: (1 , rr;rrs nrd/d,i�I)lrrlp:+l".04010'rr; 1( 1H /.tr.r 1, 12ll ,1 i_' 14 .S I,., Y00 1 J,i r. r_. 013 n"{r EXHIBIT H 10 1411 rune PaIks and Ficc Iky ;ulnuIt, Iturinutanuo IIV; Ullfl(%lfrr)II (:nnuIII rarm. IlIirhrq.urn f,il/ r:r,unr.il 1 his letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen c;pof.w% for F.�ran ,Urnve. IlurhnrF-rrnr: rhrt wnVer storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnagr to a huu;r! :rnrl vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially Irfe Ihreatr,,nrrrg. Wrs twlirwe thr <;r trrz4s wr? not th,rt best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's coolr!r climate and drr;ttr!r Canters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and tll,�Ir ror)t ; rnir;t dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and welter and the soil is nchr'r whir h means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallo',-i root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and causer) damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was Purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Street Number WMA Signature To Burlmganie Parks and Rec Department Burlingame Beautification Commission Burlingame City C9unpl Dear Sr?Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive. Burlingame The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail with one causing damage to a house and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters The soil in Australia is also less nutrient•nch so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep rn of der to survive In contrast Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don t need to reach as far do&n into the soil for nutrients' The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was Purely a result of the winter storms We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 52 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January In addition Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem As compared to some other tree species they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools on the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees many of our neighboring cities 1Berkeley Oakland Mill Valley San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th 2007 we understand that Easton is a themed street and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large heavy limbs and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them These trees are not welt suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an avoid` list' If the Government of Western Australia where this is a native species has listed tnem as a hazardous tree we shouidn t be planting them in our residential communities Given this information, we don t believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive We. as residents of Easton Dr want Easton to continue to be a Chemed block We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter native to Northern California more sustainable and easier to maintain and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property pp n Name _ Signature Street Number T��. I uilnt,tanti Paiks and Rec Pepaitment, Fluiling,trile lleautifrr.:nlunr t.Urnll Burn, ltnrluutarrw Cily C;r,rmr,rl Dear SICMaitam, T hIs It>tter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen speries for La,,ton Drive. F3urlingarnr� Thc; winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a horr;r� and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe the ;e tree, are not thr! Lest option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 Ft tall and grow extremely fast (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Street Number Signature J. ,. 10 Furlirn)anu: Parks and Rec: I)epartntent. LAnIII udame Itc�auhfrc»loin Gornrru ;sion, fiurlrnrt.uns City C;rnrn,.Il Dear n:Alad,am. This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drivr , Burlinq-rme. me winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and vietter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fastz (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species. has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. TO ant N�2q Dovle),No 1_600�__ Name Street Number - -- — --- Signature City of Burlingame Petition to Apply for Establishment_ Modify or Remove a Street Tree Themed Block (Only this form can be used to 9&ther signatures) Definition of a Street Tree Themed Blocs A mrW trm tlkcta.c',i ftud it Arssmd wi a hikwA ` wbKh clot dcfNKJ %V"X t -e - ii- s1, C%tlhIl%lwJ acid trta w.01TK:j Hint Imarly (ftat'c a dwxwd t*.wd K eft sod a wm Is. r 1001- Oc tt le wt►utd he rrPLXW wish a trw of flu: (-r.tfhinlecsi dK me gwcx% The It madkAwm ('rwmw,-Wu ad Cits (t tt cs tar Ott lk'a eye cYncria when ctrnWeriny a+t"tillam-to (rl a tixmwd f+NA die pore d tiijirte3r aa1 ww Vro ilm hems ad &Waive %*Tsa►-V r�l� s{tecic�. anrturp ill (rtx divcrt►ity, t6rR ttl r{+eti�. a: .utttLertc kxiic ar rt t+ke[i. tlt�lLt tilt �?. 1t�tstr ea*ttpg pnitaletiatA. ttil�tl (il 11w #heel. tuid lire width ad plaga txi,4%, Polity to Establish, iM Wity or Remove a Themed Block • I lit: htJUtrfllLati(trr ( rrtIlMiti►ani 1*111 rM0rtnr,rrri )bc nod llhtcil(+` kt del C6) Caunecil. • 1 tt 11L1gitNi tilt licaulri'xatititi (. t►mtnnAtrtel l,+r a Herr thereed Matt a prr>y+elTj .3axr.v a Murtt .tacit �RT triptrturn ��( xt (ca.t 21 of Ilk pnplat) trwnrra tm dw Kt(-k • It► pttitifoil dw lk-awiliLatitm (.(unmIl.rtnr it. "vId, ly a 4vcirx d1MwW Nlxj tree +gwVV% or R(cm,%c a q+crtfw KwA thyn 0w Ilicincd 1114(ck I.i.t, a l,rtillmi) imixr torn a Kick .hall pdxT ulai titres (d at loll '16'• 44 ibc 1*VCM (*mere. Im the I+R k. I ttnn% lie flit " Pcti iini- %til he prtntded by the Psi.% aid Rccreatilow Dq+artsrmt wxc_ • Voititml, %W11 he forwarded tit rtw itc.mification t crmmix m fnir to the (;*rail pt e.tAN" ttrrrdit\ Or rrntuvr ;r ilictncd hlt,ck • A rutilit licatiitl• tot III lit wi by tilt. Itcaurilicaiuin ( innmr..i(n ant rrrdirkmmtn sill tv +iM I,,% .ta11 tit jilt irtf"y i)wrwrt on tilt, hltkk. • If approved by the 1kauUNcatitin ( tnww%%itm and �tr A►c ((wix►l. .rail rill &icrmitw rite %rw,, % thane in t tillaht►ruiiun with the prriperty ownm • Sc ItAwd ' thcincd" gw0ei, %ill reptacc cki.tin4 trues ttnl..rhrn an t-i"tlnx tttx K dcrrmd neer.aary ,l.t;rtrawit Ito ( iIV httlicl Street and Block Requested for Consideration ((o DO 0*-LC ?'n n+ Mark One Establish Siteet Ttr.e Species Desired Modify k!::� Remove a The.r+e4 Bocx Street Tree Themed Block Signature Form Property Owner Statement i am the Dtowrty owner at the addrress bated below and I support the Beacitification Commission and City Council in establishing this biocit as a Street Tres Themixf Bock Lgtfft+O*" RNa U •tr••r"I hlock Stiret Tree or removing this themed block Sweet Tree~ the Cary of BVWVa" fAr nod iM sf, ;Date - Property Address —property Owner Naentsl lPthMed) ._..Prop*M Owner nignotwo J n}n t ! toe 4- t.,a,sr s E- Vim_ i i lip Burlingame Paiks and Rec. Department, L3t111uigame Beautification Cornrni;ion, Hiirlingarne City Counr,il Dear Sii/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and welter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks. (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. t)0 It d Name _/5�_ Signature �4� 4,4,1 Street Number nn� � nrr�r� a ,r,�,.,rw t =s�r�itu.0 � •�„r�„r ui fir.. 1,. a �is� t r fir t ! I �t IItiU hVr• 'ten: ant,n �inv :ni/, i,ill�r,i��,. ;n1r,G .�uLi. r,il��bn.� Iii�ul ��'wervrG.rl air-� nt e:,� , ��.v "I'" Id" h,,n IhIr (A1 e ' A.0 I wit f W 414 • t ' I1.04 11•' ,g I, ,0+ 04 7I,I ',IIL- r„ I1 To Burlingame Parks and Rec Department. Burlingame Beautification Commission Burlingame City Council Dear Sir/Madam This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive. Burlingame The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fad, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive Eucalyptus trees are not parlicularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia where they thrive in a warm Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive In contrast, Northern Caldornia s climate is cooler and wetter and the sod is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients' The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle This tree was not Flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January In addition. Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem As compared to some other tree species they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley. Oakland. Mill Valley San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th. 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street. and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citnodora (or Corymbia Citnodora) trees for the theme The Eucalyptus Citnodora tree still poses similar risks (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species (2) They can grow up to 150 It tall and grow extremely fast: (3) They have the propensity to shed large heavy limbs and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an `avoid list' If the Government of Western Australia where this is a native species has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities Given this information we don t believe Eucalyptus Citrodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive Vie. as residents of Easton Or want Easton to continue to be a themed block We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property M NDce? K1qv_gq_HA,-- Name Street Number Signature to f;urlmq,11110 P;uks and Rec,, Dol,antment, Ilrnlinynnie tienuliflr.ahun Gortirm ;;inn, Hurlincl;rrne (A/ r;nunr.il Dear Sn,Aladam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen specir:s for E aslrm Drive, B(jrllny-rmr!. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one Causing d image to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Street Number 1t, Billlmt)anu• P'llks and her. I)elmltilicnt. Ituilirnl;mu, Iteaulifwahrm r!fill nnr,"irrn. firtrIll rlarn! r;ity r;our,r.it Deal Sn Atad,tm. l his Utter is 10 request YOU to reconsider GuCalyptus trees as the chosen sper,ins for f_a;ton Drive. f;urlrnlarnr: rhr� \\utter storms ut Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail. wilh one cs.uismrl darnzul, to a hou and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We bellow, lhe;e Una:. arc not tf,q, best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and weti- r winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots m[-j7,t dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast` (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an `avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a Chemed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. ±rt()CJL— -z� Name Signature Street Number to f?urlu) );une I'.IIks and Ilvc 1 lc'1r,rrin1 (1,111, Ilurluulanxt 13c aulifu.;alum (;nnnnraunr. fit rlinq:rrnrt (ahr (;uunr.il Dear SuAl adana, This letter is to request you to reconsider Cucalyplus trees as the chosen species for Faston Drive, fbrrlmrjamr! The: winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darn:rgr: to a hou and vehicle The damage could have beer) way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these trees are not the; best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast= (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property, john and be -JD& le %6 /3 6 as4rn Dr IVf� Name Signature Street Number To: Burlingame Paiks and Rec Department, flurlingarne Beautiflcnliun Cornrtiv sion, 13urling:une City Counr:il Dear SkiMadam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a housF: and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. NameJ Street Number ---------- -- Signature _ � .. • � � ., , �. I � � i � � � :. b r • , 3 . � , . , � � I'+ � 1, • f.. � t � l i f. i • t I • • , L , , r a . � . _ To: Burlingame Parks and Rec Depaltnlent. 1311011(Imile Reautificatinn Commission, 13urlin(larlm City Cowir:d Dear Sir/Madam. This lettor is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus treos as the choson species for Faslon Drivo, biirlinyarn:. Thr: winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, will) one causing darnagr; to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are nal the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots rnlJst dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name /7 ' , Signature 1 JJ t; .A CT V A/ Street Number ''Illtj-na:IPLrµ^Ipj,-r,ill'.'?jjryulmi. rxwalornafnsFnialn—.or ,1,,V,tn !:ualvalI°-if'L- 1llittiLL11dS14.tltgl 1,0ps llwv l anbg rFly a4ignp/!mint; r; ; %(114/cr/ryrnliuf-Ldn�db�r,l hlnd '1r110,'raVl;Lo:abmtn-t V_1';(jv:+u/Uubpr"11 ry�i•,linf Int1p"rtrr•iti rr l4b' nliVn,ww/.101r101i"ityR7•li!�Ir a"I%II�J•I_il lttil�i�ll_!,fl(1(L1LI��L'til- io Burlingame Parks and Rec D partment, Builingame Beautification COrnmISSIOn, fturlrngame City Council Dear Sir IMadam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. T Name Street Number __—.— _ ::r •�r.,_ - n` d+11,:-' 1�� -11'!1 lu .,111,W1 11L! I ,a1• I+tnl _!l =Y To: Burlingame Parks and Rec Department, Burlingame Beautification Commission, Burlingame City Council Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few frees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" IisP. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name — Si ure \1 n �%-G S \''Y--� VV Street Number lhMrs llo,w/ alf�Pn,nr]�nO7:hON SOI711ornar7lP l/fr-r- A=�lt;;lif to U�h'��r' 7-rff-f001-�8, "I r; 1 hims lr':1Few anho or)y au/cno/iraIf, EES-A ;1r1Aq In V" C,1!I dr r;j h1mI =bvey ll 1: ❑ar amr:enl wa eov a�.dr]ulyhr:a irn dl fi r_� t II I., rsl 1, ,_n�nt,l n_r140100L,3c1874edre32 INN ? 11 1Fl?Y11 41DO I /1 •I I 1 -,, II, I_,11 liz Burlingame Parks and Rec; Department, Billlingrune Beautification Commission, Bnrlingarne City Council Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees slay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. -,,�o�h T6kus-T Name Signature 11I ECs Street Number 'hth,5://vv:vpi r�;f rr_'.l'liup:Ynnvvhnv rnrn/nllya[115;1]j;jf/h�11;1(1ay,i11YL'WSi/tllCil1Y1=W:CCl�h2�l-St�11 L1�hlL'.11llll � l eil,s luivrvv anb,l�nv r,ul�Lli;unr,r;�,-YO 1 Gli.nrygil u;i�ra6 w�1„ri I dint 'htiU:alvivlYl1);. nrulVi.f`uiv;nil,u,U�.cdun>,/I;rl,iLL,r,artiiF.i+'l!_L'tSYL1LL1L'jt1(tr1h4iINlt��I.___1_Ihl,l_Idly'!�lyiKli`t;'I`�I`�;�ht,It`Sh�.tp;y lip t3tnlingame I',vks and Rev, Department, lluilingame Heautification Commission, Burlingame City Council Dear Sil Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees failing since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. QcA,,r,,_ Name Street Number Signature i nnn•„t!ntaIAtI,Ay IIii,louI, ]',.I I,. inn I -t hun 1nr h t!j _ - _. ri•,.,....'it�l4lrntYltlr,rrnn�tlortlihtl ,•;nrd.lInr,t-'t•,n;lhlrtdrtelctL!r/4i111),foVfHY•I�,1, 1'I1n61:11.1tir`d11,.,-)r1.1'1,,1, I f To: 131111ingame Talks and 12ec Depattment, Butlingame 1.3eaut1fir.:1ti011 Cornrnission, BurUngame City Council Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and Match 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry Summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not Flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Street Number Signature v es/euralvntus/ern:atvnhrs-Iree rnot-dineulp him _ ,:.Yr;lrYrnrAnb!a-rrinudnf0 him i I:1 0 orI-'ji,'N'-(tpar.utr n,lhI spla vpa )car/40111 o-Dcttl 74udt 321 h1.1:' 1.16 a 1, r , l i A ,11.t,� To: Nullingame Parks and Rec Depaltmenl, [it n[illy ame Beaulilicalion Conrinission, Burlingame City Council Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Signature ) ;�?s (n� Street Number - riovr rgln/r,r n:,ii-n1.11It Ii.r /rl Iraly1)111 11(;IIW;IIIS-rrPr-. r n o I d: II 11'I(1F I,t 1$ -"�rl1r/r,�r��rinn-r_iLnr, r 113S1Lf in,,I,_A"U, d Ir—t� n`,fl L�.illry�,_il._I/41i )Wo, 1I W/4. IIr 1.. 111,1 1.' I 1 1 h , I I Y 1, Jki to Bu11111gan10 P irks and Rec. Doliminient, Builmoame, Beautification Commission, Burlingarnc! Gity Co!mr,il Dear Sii,Madani. This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingarne rh,. winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them, These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. , I�CVI A E �9JS Name Street Number Signal re :':.d.r r o.,.r;�-<•Y:•.:ll�ei./r r..t._.... .__._ .. ."�."it.;! -�. r!i:.Stir:t�iS!-.��t:�sittl:S�J'�tILT� r-.. �•.:r: „3 .,r s--,ut. 'r -^. c, a; .r ri�li;r "�+rIR" l,arr-321!•r1.3?11� - h To Iluilinklmile I'mks ,Ind I�)rr I)ej mutnwnt. IiurIII il:mu! Flf'autifir.ation (,onInii , In, Fit rh rl.irnr• rail/ f;oimr.il Dim[ `u;t11,1,i,un, III IS ICtiPI Is to request you to 1cconsider Eucalyptus Ire es as the chosen specie, for I:w.ton Drive. F;urhnrjarne The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnage to a hurl .e and -0hrcle 1-he damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trey , are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm. Mediterranean climate with dr/ summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 281h, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fastz (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. c t L t i __�•j��l � _ Name Si ature 1 d l 2- F,? � � Street Number .. :..,," .,: , , ., � _,. ,., ,�,u,. _... - .emu„•. �..,- „_ r , „ ..,,,, lip Pillimilame I'mks and tier Ihopmuinu-nl, Ililt linq'Ime Iteaulifu;alion Cnnirnrsstori, flurlin(pirn ! (,,p/ r;rat,nr,it t)ea i SII,MIdam, III is letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen speries for Far ton Drvm, Fiurluigarna fhrt whiter Slornis In Fch and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnagr' to a hrri, and vehicle 1 he damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe thesr! trnr!S are nrnt the hest option for Easton Dnve. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" Iist3. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Street Number _ Signature To. Bulhngame Parks and Rec Depailment, Limlingaine Beautification Commission, f3urlrrlgarne City Council Dear SirlMadam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees slay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fastz (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. lill[�9fn V1 �U�VLC{i Name U�6__W06DO- Avt�_, Street Number od 'h'!r%!jmo g w d,-rungP rnmrQn1,11rr•nl-d/Ir,•r,,S;�r.�fy[�l�iWl�•nrslv['�Isi1 In •r-rnnl rl:ur ;x,,• i� m > M r cs;h,l:vv :rnh >> ;';a,hlir;rn,., -"ili lr.lry q,m 'IIlr,tillviuri par l iota rd+..r ri"'i ;j,dj'w,h.-i!i. 11.r1,i,..:.r riu�iti n+, `rrlrv.rld• .r tl 101WI ic WI A 11 04r'1•Ia'ha 1r,000•sfle IL, O:i.A 1"r To. Burlinpame Parks and Rec Detrnrtrnont, Hurlrngame [tecaulifrcrallan Cornrnieslon, Burlingame City Council Dear Sir/Madam, This letter ha to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees Ins the chosen spades for Esrnton Drive, Burlinp�me. Thc. winter stoats in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fall, witYt ono causing darnagej 10 a houso and vehicle The damage could have baPn way worse rand potontially life Ihreatening We bnlieve thrrlg free% are not the beN option for Gaston Drive. Eucalyptus troos are not parliculady welt -suited for Northern California clue 10 the rogion's tooter climate and +yeller winters Eucalyptus trees are Illative to Australia, whero they thrive In a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters The soil in Austn3fia Is olso less nulrlont-rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots mast d,ve deep in order to survive. In contrast, Norlhom Cafdfornia'n climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptlblo to failures. WO witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Or and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not nagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the fariure was purely a result of the winter storms We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly, Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense rsk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mfll Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the 13eaubfication Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007. we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Carymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses simiiar nsks, (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (d) They are afire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Govemment of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list". If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native s!>ecies, has flsted them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this Information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a thorned block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter• native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name a i s Signature ��i 1l�ti•� t;�ti��-c� �t1pi Street Number 'IIIhx!!kyxrrrra��lr�Iinnr•n,- k s �.--.+--.—_.,a,� n4 m.rrrr i { fr � I rslnlr•air r rn. rF f: r —_ +uaau+:+u'�1 �rrhh••• r7 �, �. {' `r' kL':112G1�+•t ii .RU ai tL`L'.'_�+::�1,t.'.i1:. E{ * To: 131,11111u1a111e Parks and Rec Department, I3urlinganle Beautification Commission, Burlingarnr City Council Dear Sir/Madam, This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingarne. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. G1,zwg t'r+' �*,,,,A Name Signature Street Number h" ` ;±USii]YRtUS' !itit1YMU5 41ec 1S, Ui tIiilueJILai ' r�"FS ;ir; t�t� wn!;r r ry•r aulrnr;ll�ainaea-7rf 1f;{rorin 1Ua_, _cdr, igr w." i!M1 'r'',s,_�v:� irhan•.-nt f..�,�evaitiil�h-v tLLrn5ltml1.t-Lj„,!ttiLrtil;t.r:IL:±lml_t(„jl)f0!'rfr,1(1t tir-<it,��, 11 1'u1111111,111) 1'a1ks AIId I"ec Ilelrutrlwill, I3tnIIngame IlCautiflcaIion Cornnn„ron, EturIinq:rrrie Glt/ l,r,tlnr.fl hc:.�f tifr.M,viiant. This letter Is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingame rhe, winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a house and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. Name Si ture T — -Igo, Street Number 't....,n` r',..-rrn i•nr:�..rr.�nr f'.- -.c r il"(--I Ic I.. I l'in, I non 't 7r" �'tlnf!'q r�-T 9Utr ' n^r'yr' -,1f ratlrr-l1—I10 lriH7•ic1t '*3'IY--1•I�1. `'•tlr- -'t 1'(1 11urlmtl.ame Parks ;unit Rieu [)vpnrlme�nt, BIIrIIrIq"rule 13eautifir,;itrnn Corrtrnis ,lr)n, Hiirhnda(rie city (Ir)r)rlr,ll Dear Sir/Madam. This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Burlingarne. The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damage to a hou" and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and welter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast(3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid' list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. it atone Yk5 m a4c�� 1111 C-�h i C I Name Street Number (I [,1,N�A Signa re httr SllYtpn r•ar!e ut,QVnn v(r a inns/e.nit rti ;r Jtnr•,.j y1y11YL'ti1 1LllCclt>12111� L'L'1 ILS LS1:1LLt li'lltill r 1:[tl„Ylvn a anb+) nov„ ih]nLnuu•,a,_71) Il 4 a),na,w . ti, dhn❑ lilnd '�fOlis "fray/ oarh�rrrvil w+ru y upto dilr d r, �I rr �,:rlo.n,r •t t ,f4 r-, r, ,v {1 ,no ,. R/. �� 1� t'1 0.l2 t. ;V`.N1 I+ tC• rh i_...�Li,1Y � < . , l 1- 1 _ c, i t 1. tfiln:tt+-06 t 2cl 10 14uIInUamtw I',aiks and I"eC hrltartnuvil, Iiurhnrinnu, Iieautitu ahun (:nnuni- drrn. Iinrlrrvl:rrnr r;ity r,nunr,il hcaI ";n Mattana, i-his letter is to request you to 1et:005,00r I uc'rtlyltlus lines as the chosen species for f i-lon Drive. flnrlrnq:rrnrr f hrr Wutter storms it, I eh ;and March 2023 have caused a few trees to Fail, with Fine causing rinrriarin to a house and vehicle The damage. Mould have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We helicve these trees are, not Ihr! hest option for Easton have. Eucalvptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter %vinte rs Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia• where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees slay smaller and their roots mu ,t dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer whirh means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2(3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. C�ynj�tr+�, ie\ \a Name C Signature Street Number C( o; fair _ _ �..',::-�.�'. _'... . ",'::.,7.. _':z..�.ci-5 _1..:_.�_ t..:.' �". �'i�� -.; �'YLt �: ..�:.: I^s.l �l as n,is». j•h,` to Imilnrgmuo Paiks and Net- I)r1wilnicnl. f1mluulanne Ili;rlrtiflc;tlrrm (:noun , ;roil, fiudirig;iiirrt Ctty t't-al Sli'Mad,un, l Ills latter Is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus tines as the (:hO5er1 sftr r;lns for F:a;ton Unvrr, fiurhnrd.rrn: fhe winter storms In f eb and Man;h 2073 have caused a few trees to f:nl, with one c;:nrsln<l rdarn ige to a hnusq and �rhlrlo. 1 he damakie could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe the;(! tmns are; riot Ihr: Lest option for Easton Drive Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California clue to the regron's cooler cllrrrate and wetter Winters Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm. Mediterranean climate with dry sumnmers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots roust dive deep in order to survive In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses Immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property _ �J �QI� � maw_ ��o�{- ��rtY �-✓e_ Name Street Number --- _ %1 mature .. _ 1.1a'jt,;.,•cI"".1VNLf<`,-�IIr to I'It lluILI,ynIt' I'alks irnd IN I� I vp,utnIt nII I.tullillgnfIw Ileaulltir::drtal Con IItIIIcrrI, fItIrhngarnn (;Ity (:nun.Il P0,11 6u rMadam 1 ItIs tether Is to request YOU to reconsider Fucalyplus Imes as the chosen sfrcrirs for f warm Driv(!. Fll lrhnl<'Irrio rhr, %vintei storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few tees to fail, with one Causing rdarnagn to a and vehicle 1 he damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these Imes am not the best option for Faston Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm. Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their root-, mu ,t dive deep in order to sulvlve In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil Is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list. If the Government of Western Australia. where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. h c�i�uti ern. 13 2 � er Name �- ignature ooC� faS-� /3rtV e Street Number ,'FAa I,] err,It,., t: t' ,'r il•__ �. r k'c?La:':il`-ells',isi...�.:.:�i�C�i:i*!t14=.a1i.'. fr tl. rl�•r �I�:Y .;1�1:'1�: 1 _ i�} I /(;;I11,1 ! I! , .I I fl ill ll to L;urhnganu: !'alhs and Rcc Depaltmcnt, ilurlingame Reautlhcation Gonnnission, Iturlim a nr! City Counr,d Dear Sn,Madam. This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, BUrling:IrnF Thr: winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fait, with one causing ctarnage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucatyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry Summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are afire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a lhemed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. . NN, ame l j Street Number lSnnalure .irl ,� �',I;1 i�1.•.:.J .�I� i!.'/1,1�1'.ii ��i.. ,l�f;lii} It, "'t da jl -1� a li 11 L]P.:" it r r Ij 111, 1 -- ..:.11 1¢ .E. i'_-! :...„�7 1 it I / t - f� I;' Bf„H ' I fir I, A to Nutlua.t,11110. and Rcc Pe paitment, Uurlingranrc (tc:urlilicaGon coma ie ,inn, Hurhncd:nnn (.rt j (,owir,il Dear Su Aladam. phis letter IS to request you to reconsider L=uc.alyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive Hurhnrlamr! ihr; winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing cdarnagra to a hou ;e and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe the trer!, are not thr? best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wRtt� r winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be afire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. P-C a_,�r� Name Signature Zo0q Street Number To Burlingame Parks and Rec Department Burlingame Beautification Commission Burlingame City Council Dear Siri'Madam This letter is to request you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive Burlingame The winter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fad with one causing damage to a house and vehicle The damage could have been way worse and potentialfy life threatening We believe these trees are not the best option for Easton Dave Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well suited for Northern California due to the region s cooler climate and wetter winters Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia where they thrive in a warm. Mediterranean climate with dry summers and maid winters The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the tr«•5 stay smaller and their roots must d-ve deep in order to survive In contrast Northern California s climate is cooler and wetter and the sod is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don t need to reach as far down into the sod for nutrients' The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees failing since January In addition Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem As compared to some other tree species they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high nsk trees is not prudent Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley Oakland Mill Valley San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th 2007 we understand that Easton is a themed street and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Cdnodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme Tne Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar asks (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species (2) They can grow up to 150 It tail and grow extremely fast- (3t They have the propensity to shed large heavy I rubs and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them These trees are not well su led for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid' list' It the Government of Western Australia where this is a native species has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn t be planting them in our residential communities Given this information we don t believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive We as residents of Easton Dr want Easton to continue to be a themed block We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter native to Northern California more sustainab!e and easier to maintain and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property i Name 1 � Signature treet Number to I"u111nq.11110 Palkc and floc Pepallnit'nt, R1111r11c1-lnle I{e:1I111(n allnn Lnrnnmr. nn f{Inlin t.vn„ rill h,ia1 511 N1,1,1,1m, 1 h1S Iettrl IS to requrst Vrou to reainSlder Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Eaaun Driw!, rfrrrlirigarne� the Hinter Storms In 1=e11 ;and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing damagy! to a hnu;r! and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening We believe these tree-, arr! Tint thr! hest option for Easton Drive. Eucalvphls trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warn. Mediterranean climate with dry Summers and mild winters The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots roust dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property �42'M1e j6,& ` l%'uf/C'h 04�1!rr , Narr� Street Number Si nature to Uuiling,ime P,uks and Rec Depaitilienl, Ituilin(tame BeauUfu;ahun Cornrnissiun, flurhw1wric> City Goijw.il Dear 5ir.Mada111, This letter is to I-Oquest you to reconsider Eucalyptus trees as the chosen species for Easton Drive, Rialin(jarne The «antes storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees to fail, with one causing darnage to a house and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threatening. We believe these treys are not the best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Northern California due to the region's cooler climate and wetter winters. Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be afire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast2 (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. k oti ) / - b r-, Street Number _ ------____—' nr-1)_ J_LFI_h1s31..ilYG1ll51,51C@llC1dZIL�(Il41�'.i(I��,�h11 iivr,r:rpr)ir..a c. In ,dwa II!ml To Put Iintlatile I'arks and lire' Ilrplit ) it' nl, Iluihny,mie Iie;tutiht.;itum C: miniv;•uon, fit riuularnrr (,ity (:uitnr.d Dear Su; Madam, 1 his letter is to request you to reconsuiet Euucalyplus trees as the, chosen sper.ies for I zr ;ton f )nve-. Fiurlin(Orn,�- rhrn \+inter storms in Feb and March 2023 have caused a few trees (n fait, with one cmrsing damage! to a hrntsr! and vehicle. The damage could have been way worse and potentially life threalening We believe thE'Se tree; arr! not thr�- best option for Easton Drive. Eucalyptus trees are not particularly well -suited for Notthern California due to the region's cooler clirnatc and v/ettf�r winters, Eucalyptus trees are native to Australia, where they thrive in a warm, Mediterranean climate with dry summers and mild winters. The soil in Australia is also less nutrient -rich so the trees stay smaller and their roots must dive deep in order to survive. In contrast, Northern California's climate is cooler and wetter and the soil is richer which means Eucalyptus trees grow very quickly with more shallow roots because their roots don't need to reach as far down into the soil for nutrients'. The high winds from winter storms combined with the Eucalyptus trees' shallow root structure makes them susceptible to failures. We witnessed the impact of this during the storms in Feb 2023 when a large tree fell on 1809 Easton Dr and caused damage to the house and vehicle. This tree was not flagged as a cause for concern prior to that and the failure was purely a result of the winter storms. We saw similar tree failures in Coyote Point, with over 62 healthy Eucalyptus trees falling since January. In addition, Eucalyptus trees can be invasive and can disrupt the local ecosystem. As compared to some other tree species, they tend to be a fire hazard and drop limbs regularly. Limb dropping from such high elevations poses immense risk to life and property. Several houses on Easton Drive have young kids and there are two schools in the neighborhood and having high risk trees is not prudent. Due to all the issues with Eucalyptus trees, many of our neighboring cities (Berkeley, Oakland, Mill Valley, San Francisco) have been removing Eucalyptus trees and restricting planting more in the future. In reviewing the notes of the Beautification Commission meeting held on June 28th, 2007, we understand that Easton is a themed street, and the committee has chosen Eucalyptus Citriodora (or Corymbia Citriodora) trees for the theme. The Eucalyptus Citriodora tree still poses similar risks: (1) They tend to be invasive and can hurt the local ecosystem and native species, (2) They can grow up to 150 ft tall and grow extremely fast' (3) They have the propensity to shed large, heavy limbs, and (4) They are a fire hazard due to the flammable oils in them. These trees are not well suited for urban environments and the Government of Western Australia placed them on an "avoid" list'. If the Government of Western Australia, where this is a native species, has listed them as a hazardous tree, we shouldn't be planting them in our residential communities. Given this information, we don't believe Eucalyptus Citriodora is the right tree species for Easton Drive. We, as residents of Easton Dr, want Easton to continue to be a themed block. We are requesting that you consider replacing Eucalyptus trees with a different species that is shorter, native to Northern California, more sustainable and easier to maintain, and doesn't pose as significant a risk to life and property. —j� Name Signa re Street Number 'n �, �,;•.�r _�. .nr-,_. �- I�r h .�.ur 9iYf.tnsln+r,-fr,nt.r!,ftri3�i.• hlni .,i f�,�_. null �-i /t.ir, 11'il{Iris', �?� fit l•l,.r1� i.'tl-i.t. I 1 ��'... ..__.---t._ _. ._._, � �' �' EXHIBIT I Q +ALBOA AVE Q 0 1309 BALBOA AVE 1600 EASTON DR Damp Tau* l Gf 6, • �'� j� - 16oy E-zsto� \ M o Div °� cauyogo- \ Q Q 12 CORTEZ AVE Q O Q 1608 EASTON DR Q Q 0 YNU y6L h,41. Q \ Q 1601 EASTON DR 1612 EASTON DR 1616 EASTON DR 1605 EASTON DR Q� Q i CIO O Q Q 1613 EASTON DR 1609 EASTON DR QpZ 1280 CORTEZ AVE a 1274 CORTEZ AVE Q 0 70 � O `Q 1613 EAST 1311 CORTEZ AVE Q � flt 1280 CORTEZ AVE O 1 J ,w, ^^ rn Q 1700 EASTON OR Q C ° ME �� 0-O / YX ° ° Q 1704 EASTON DR 1712 EASTON OR ..n fU Q ° Q 1265 CORTEZ AVE 0 1713 EASTCt1 OR OC 1709 EASTON DR 1705 EASTON DR Q ° O O E 1715 EASTON DR (1719 EASTOH ORSWfMv��(�j�Sus►e 1 1272 CABRILLC AVE 1309 CABRILLO AVE c` o EuN' aame Library E- -'ruri Branch 1804 EASTON DR ftNvlH o r� o 1808 EASTON DR 0 �t J�t7 WE AVE 1812 EASTON DR / a �uw" f Q \ 1304 DRAKE AVE ° o ° DRAKE AVE x 0 1719 EASTON DR c ° Q Ile � o 1285 CABRILLO AVE 1805 EASTON DR 5et�� o Uoc�ai (�ardo�c 1815 EASTON DR 1809 EASTON OR s it-q�r� A n� ft2KAl2AVE X1264 f A�ayvroo ►9 DRAKE AVE 1301 DRAKE AVE 1 1906 EASTON DR 1908 EASTON DR ,ERNAL AVE 0 1912 EASTON DR w u I I o f 1�, 0 0 t7rd� o �L0 0 1304 BERNAL AVE f� Q a �a KO'S ce C.¢aN11'dtJ� 0 c 0 0 1911 EASTO 0 I m 0 AVE Eq 2000 EAST0N DR Y 1260 BERNAL AVE L O �o 0 1270 E 0 0 1 0 AVE C Gf.Vlc1,,e/V l IM 1907 EASTON DR 1256 BERPI / 1305 BERNAL AVE 2000 EASTON @R i uj 2004 EASTON DR 2%8 EASTON DR i i C� 1 ANCOUVER AVE o 0 ° ro 2012 EA STON DR W v6uWVN 2020 EASTON DR o ro o.. O Q o 0 0 0 2100 EASTON DR i� A, i 1260 BERNAL 0 O 1255 BERNAL AVE 2013 EASTON OR Sial� 2017 EASTON DR r 1236 VANCOUVER AVE / 125 EXHIBIT J OFFICAL STREE TREE LIST - CITY OF BURLINGAME- PARKS DIVISION BURLINGAME 850 Burlingame Ave., Burlingame, CA 94010 phone: (650) 558-7330 • fax: (650) 696-7216 parksadmin@burlingame.org Click the links below to see a sample of the tree. TREES TO BE PLANTED IN AREAS 6' WIDE AND OVER Height at Botanical Name Common Name Maturity Description Acer rubrum Red Maple 40'-50' DECIDUOUS: Fast growth; lobed, green leaves; brilliant fall color. Cinnamomum Camphor 40'-50' EVERGREEN: Slow to moderate growth; yellow green camphora aromatic leaves; tiny yellow flowers in spring. Magnolia grandiflora Samuel Sommers 30' EVERGREEN: Fast growth; upright branches; dark green foliage with rusty bronze coloring on leaf under side; white flowers in spring and summer. Platanus aceriflolia London Plane 40'-60' DECIDUOUS: Fast growth; large, lobe, maple like Sycamore/Columbia leaves; sheds old bark; new bark smooth, cream color. Quercus agrifolia Coast Live Oak 40'-70' EVERGREEN: Moderate to fast growth; dense foliage; round holly -like leaves; round -headed, spreading crown. Quercus coccinea Scarlet Oak 40'-70' DECIDUOUS: Moderate to fast growth; high, open branches; large, bright green leaves turn, red in fall. Quercus rubra Red Oak 40'-70' DECIDUOUS: Fast growth; spreading branches with round crown. Ulmus Accolade Elm 60'-80' DECIDUOUS: Fast growth; graceful vase shape limbs; glossy dark green foliage, yellow in fall. Subject to Availability.