HomeMy WebLinkAboutMin - BC - 2016.04.07BURLINGAME BEAUTIFICATION COMMISSION
April 7,2016
The regularly scheduled meeting of the Beautification Commission was called to order at 6:30 pm by
Commissioner McQuaide.
ROLL CALL
Present: Commissioner McQuaide, Hunt, Hinckle, Kirchner and Kearney
Absent: None
Staff: P & R Director Glomstad, City Arborist Disco and City Attorney Kathleen Kane
MINUTES
Kearney made a motion to approve March 3, 2016 minutes with the correction to the Residential
Landscape Award date for 2017. The motion was seconded by Hinckle and unanimously approved.
CORRESPONDENCE
None
PUBLIC COMMENT
None
NEW BUSINESS
1. Appeal of 1480 Highway Road Permit
Director Glomstad read staff report provided and Arborist Disco explained process of permit issuance,
approval timeline and qualifications for removal.
Nina and Anthony Wang, appellants spoke to the Commission regarding their appeal based on privacy
and protection provided by the tree.
Melinda Saunders, neighbor, spoke on behalf of the neighborhood impact regarding the proposed removal
of the tree.
Sarah Hillhouse, Coldwell Banker Realtor, spoke regarding property value the tree provides to
homeowners.
Arborist Disco answered Commissioners questions regarding health of tree, replanting of existing area,
structure and safety of tree, possible replacement issues and pruning of existing tree regarding root
system.
Commissioner Hinckle made a motion to uphold the appeal and not allow removal of the tree at this time.
The findings to support this motion include the condition that Mr. and Mrs. Wang have a certified arborist
write a proposal to have the tree significantly pruned on their side of the fence in order to balance the
canopy to compensate for the removal of the roots for the new driveway, the work will occur within 8
weeks or the appeal will be denied, the expense will be the responsibility of the Wang's, and the proposal
must be reviewed by the City Arborist before a tree company performs any work.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Hunt. Motion passed 4-1.
2. Tree Ordinance Revisions
City Attorney Kathleen Kane gave an overview of the Tree Ordinance study session. She shared with
Commissioners the Council presentation and protections of private/city trees. Items included the need to
streamline the appeal process between Planning and Beautification Commissions, and build a better
review/appeal process for information between both Commissions requiring more information shared
during the process. Kathleen handed out a questionnaire to help facilitate the discussion. The contents
included what type of trees to protect, how to determine proper replacement tree species, who should be
allowed to appeal, and the types of penalties. City Attorney Kane asked that all Commissioners provide
answers and submit them to her.
OLD BUSINESS
1. 2016 Business Landscape Award - Timeline
Commissioner Hinckle reported no updates.
REPORTS
1. Parks and Recreation Director Glomstad
None
2. City Arborist
Removal of Carrotwood trees and replacement of Crepe Myrtles on Broadway is almost complete.
Spring planting of 85 trees will take place in two weeks.
3. Commissioner Kirchner
None
4. Commissioner Hinckle
None
5. Commissioner McQuaide
None
6. Commissioner Hunt
None
7. Commissioner Kearney
El Camino Elm trees are coming along nicely.
The next Beautification Commission meeting is May 3, 2016. There being no further business, the
meeting adjourned at 8:33pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Maggie Martin for
Gina Borba
Recording Secretary